Life of Pi Movie: Ang Lee Visual Splendor Will Not Live Up to the Book

There’s been a lot of buzz about the visual splendor of Ang Lee’s film adaptation of Yann Martel’s 2001 novel, Life of Pi. I found the trailer impressive and intriguing, but I don’t plan to see the movie. Here’s why:

The novel is all about the internal life. Some of the emotional elements, the fear, hopelessness, and wonder, could potentially be translated to film with good acting and music. What can’t is the meditative state that the reader is propelled to along with Pi, which is the element of the book that left the deepest impression on me as a reader. 

Most of the story takes place with Pi lost at sea, alone on a boat with a Bengal tiger. Obviously there’s very little dialogue; the story is about Pi’s internal struggles, his discovery of his own fortitude and ability to finding peace in even this terrifying and strenuous situation. Being lost at sea, isolated from the rest of humanity, is a pretty blatant metaphor for turning inward and developing the power of the mind.

Through his wonderful and descriptive writing, Martel brings the reader to a lesser degree of the same kind of mental calm that Pi finds. Reading about what Pi goes through, and creating mental images of the strange island he discovers, the sea turtles he catches, and the endless days and nights, cycling unchecked, the reader, too, goes inward and gains distance from the external world.

That’s something that just can’t be replicated with film — no matter how stunning it is. Creating the images and projecting them on a screen to be passively consumed is a far cry from testing the abilities of the human mind by provoking it to conjure its own images of these phenomenal things.

In general, I prefer books to movies for this same reason — I don’t like to see movies based on books that I love because they obscure the images I’ve come up with for what characters or landscapes look like. I know that not everyone feels this way, and I know that film has its own unique advantages as a form of expression. But given the subject matter of this book and its utility as a tool for internal examination and even meditation, it just seems inappropriate and futile to attempt to translate it to film, a more external medium by nature.

Watch the trailer: 

<iframe width="640" height="360" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/j9Hjrs6WQ8M?feature=player_detailpage" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

But for the full experience, buy the book instead.

How much do you trust the information in this article?

Lilly O'Donnell

Lilly O'Donnell is a freelance writer, currently working on her first book.

MORE FROM

‘Insecure’ season two is television for us, by us — and it’s even better than before

Creator Issa Rae shouldn't sweat the Emmy snub — her connection with her core audience is what really makes this series shine.

We talked to military experts about who will win the Iron Throne

Does Dany have a chance? Historians, tacticians and scholars weigh in on the ultimate outcome of 'Game of Thrones.'

‘Game of Thrones’ Season 7, Episode 2 Trailer: New alliances may form in “Stormborn”

Jon Snow and Daenerys Targaryen may have an unexpected intermediary.

Tyler, the Creator is still a “walking paradox” on the rumor-baiting ‘Flower Boy’

Is he queer? Maybe. Does he know how to use the speculation to further his art? Definitely.

Note to Ryan Murphy: ‘American Horror Story’ reveals don’t need to be a scavenger hunt

The title and premiere date of the seventh season of 'American Horror Story' were revealed Thursday.

‘Wet Hot American Summer: Ten Years Later’ proves sometimes it’s OK to skip the reunion

If you're looking to trim down your Netflix consumption, start by avoiding this pointless sequel series.

‘Insecure’ season two is television for us, by us — and it’s even better than before

Creator Issa Rae shouldn't sweat the Emmy snub — her connection with her core audience is what really makes this series shine.

We talked to military experts about who will win the Iron Throne

Does Dany have a chance? Historians, tacticians and scholars weigh in on the ultimate outcome of 'Game of Thrones.'

‘Game of Thrones’ Season 7, Episode 2 Trailer: New alliances may form in “Stormborn”

Jon Snow and Daenerys Targaryen may have an unexpected intermediary.

Tyler, the Creator is still a “walking paradox” on the rumor-baiting ‘Flower Boy’

Is he queer? Maybe. Does he know how to use the speculation to further his art? Definitely.

Note to Ryan Murphy: ‘American Horror Story’ reveals don’t need to be a scavenger hunt

The title and premiere date of the seventh season of 'American Horror Story' were revealed Thursday.

‘Wet Hot American Summer: Ten Years Later’ proves sometimes it’s OK to skip the reunion

If you're looking to trim down your Netflix consumption, start by avoiding this pointless sequel series.