New Study Proves What Other Countries Have Known All Along About Trans Soldiers

New Study Proves What Other Countries Have Known All Along About Trans Soldiers

A new study has determined the Pentagon's exclusionary policy regarding transgender personnel in the military is outdated, unethical and inconsistent with military standards after the repeal of "don't ask, don't tell."

The Palm Center, a think tank for public policy on issues of gender and sexuality, in collaboration with former U.S. Surgeon General Joycelyn Elders, released the study last week that contends "there is no compelling medical reason for the ban." Furthermore, the groundbreaking study claims reforming extant policy "is really a simple matter of updating references to outdated medical science and removing unnecessary barriers to enlistment and retention."

Approximately 15,450 service members — 8,800 active members and roughly 6,600 in reserves — as well as more than 134,000 veterans identify as transgender in the military. However, all these trained personnel are subject to discharge under current military code

Army Reserve Capt. and Kuwait veteran Sage Fox experienced this process firsthand, after she began living as a woman and was promptly placed on inactive status, a step from discharge.


Image Credit: AP/Rich Pedroncelli

According to the Palm Center's report, "Medical regulations requiring the discharge of transgender personnel are inconsistent with how the military regulates all other medical and psychological conditions ... and transgender-related conditions appear to be the only gender-related conditions that require discharge irrespective of fitness for duty."

Additional findings concluded, from the report:

- There is no compelling medical rationale for banning transgender military service, and medical regulations requiring the discharge of all transgender personnel are inconsistent with how the military regulates medical and psychological conditions.

- Medical conditions related to transgender identity are the only gender-related conditions requiring discharge irrespective of fitness for duty.

- Eliminating the ban would advance numerous military interests, including enabling commanders to better care for their service members.

- Other military regulations have been updated to reflect the latest consensus of psychiatric experts on mental health issues, but while that consensus no longer classifies gender non-conformity as a mental illness, military regulations have not been amended to reflect the latest understanding of the scientific community about gender non-conformity.

- The U.S. military can look to the experiences and standards of at least 12 allied militaries that allow transgender service, as well as several inclusive U.S. federal agencies, as models in formulating administrative policy to address fitness testing, records and identification, uniforms, housing and privacy for transgender military service.

GLAAD President Kate Ellis lauded the commission's recommendations, saying in a statement, "Being transgender is not an indication of illness or weakness, but living in your own skin in the face of so much judgment and adversity is courageous and should be nurtured by our armed forces, not shunned."

Indeed, it is growing increasingly clear that gender identity should not have bearing when it comes to those Americans willing to die for their nation.


This report is the latest in a series of events representing what may be the beginning of a larger sea change in America regarding the transgender community. However, the White House so far has not commented on the military's current transgender policy, and Pentagon spokesman Navy Lt. Cmdr. Nate Christensen asserted there were no revisions planned at this time.

How much do you trust the information in this article?

Marcie Bianco

Dr. Marcie Bianco is a Staff Writer at Mic, a Contributing Editor at Curve Magazine, and an adjunct associate professor at Hunter College. She has contributed to AfterEllen, Feministing, The Feminist Wire, The Huffington Post, Lambda Literary, XO Jane, and The Women’s Review of Books. She writes and lectures about ethics, from feminism to race relations. Her current writing projects include a manuscript about lesbian academic affairs and a collection of feminist essays.

MORE FROM

HBO doesn’t need ‘Confederate.’ ‘Kindred’ already exists.

Octavia Butler's masterwork is the gold standard for speculative fiction about slavery — and it would make a brilliant HBO series.

70% of Muslims still believe in the American dream, according to new Pew study

Despite high rates of discrimination, Muslims are optimistic about their lives in the United States.

Man with Nazi tattoos at Cleveland Indians game sparks outrage. The Indians’ mascot is still racist.

Swastikas are bad. So is Chief Wahoo.

Baton Rouge police chief resigns after a year of political turmoil over Alton Sterling shooting

Baton Rouge's mayor had campaigned on a promise to replace the city's police chief, in the wake of Alton Sterling's shooting death.

‘Whose Streets?’ film highlights Ferguson activists’ battle with the trauma of protests

Brittany Ferrell, an organizer of the Ferguson Uprising, says a new documentary about Black Lives Matter protests shows why activists should be more intentional about checking in on each other.

Minneapolis police chief resigns after fatal shooting of Australian woman

Minneapolis Police Chief Janeé Harteau announced in a Facebook post that she is stepping aside.

HBO doesn’t need ‘Confederate.’ ‘Kindred’ already exists.

Octavia Butler's masterwork is the gold standard for speculative fiction about slavery — and it would make a brilliant HBO series.

70% of Muslims still believe in the American dream, according to new Pew study

Despite high rates of discrimination, Muslims are optimistic about their lives in the United States.

Man with Nazi tattoos at Cleveland Indians game sparks outrage. The Indians’ mascot is still racist.

Swastikas are bad. So is Chief Wahoo.

Baton Rouge police chief resigns after a year of political turmoil over Alton Sterling shooting

Baton Rouge's mayor had campaigned on a promise to replace the city's police chief, in the wake of Alton Sterling's shooting death.

‘Whose Streets?’ film highlights Ferguson activists’ battle with the trauma of protests

Brittany Ferrell, an organizer of the Ferguson Uprising, says a new documentary about Black Lives Matter protests shows why activists should be more intentional about checking in on each other.

Minneapolis police chief resigns after fatal shooting of Australian woman

Minneapolis Police Chief Janeé Harteau announced in a Facebook post that she is stepping aside.