One Headline Sums Up Everything Wrong With How the Media Treats Transwomen

One Headline Sums Up Everything Wrong With How the Media Treats Transwomen

Sensationalized, transphobic reporting is nothing new in media, but Rupert Murdoch's Courier-Mail hit an all-time low with its piece on the homicide of a transgender woman in Australia. 

The paper paired the murder-suicide of the victim, Mayang Prasetyo, and her boyfriend, Marcus Volke, with two distasteful headlines: "Monster Chef and the She-Male" and, inside, "Ladyboy and the Butcher."

Source: Twitter

Prasetyo was born in Indonesia but was living in Brisbane with Volke, whom friends say she married in 2013 (although the marriage was not legally recognized in Australia). According to the Independent, police were called to Volke's apartment Saturday night after neighbors complained of a bad smell. Officer discovered Volke, who was allegedly in the process of "cooking" some Prasetyo's body parts in chemicals. Volke escaped the police but was found later, "in an industrial bin, where he appeared to have taken his life."

The savage nature of the crime did not seem to faze Courier-Mail editors, who treated the tragedy as another chance to splash a woman in a bikini on the cover. Not surprisingly, readers responded with immediate outage, expressing their anger on Twitter and with a Change.org petition, which has garnered more than 25,000 signatures. 

Members of the Brisbane trans community are pressing the Courier-Mail to make a formal apology and "request[ing] that future articles relating to the transgender and sex worker communities are in line with [its] Code of Conduct," which requires the paper to "not make pejorative reference to a person's race, nationality, color, religion, marital status, sex, sexual preferences, age or physical or mental capacity."

The petitioners also ask the paper to "run an article about the prevalence of gender-related violence in Australia and worldwide, with the latest statistics showing 1,509 reported murders in the last six years."

The Courier-Mail acknowledged the petition through a tepid apology Wednesday, titled "Victim's memory should be valued." The editorial does not apologize for its transphobic language. Instead, it seems to congratulate the paper on its reporting, noting Prasetyo should be remembered "for her cheerful and friendly disposition":

"Mayang Prasetyo was the innocent victim of a horrendous crime, killed by the man she should have been most able to trust.

"She should be remembered — as we reported yesterday — for her cheerful and friendly disposition, and for the care she had showed her family and loved ones in Indonesia.

"Many believe that yesterday we presented Mayang's story in a way that was disrespectful to her memory.

"The Courier-Mail had no intention of diminishing the value of Mayang's life, or to add to the grief being felt by her family."

People are not buying it.

According to the Guardian, the Courier-Mail's editor is coming under increasing fire on social media, but has not received as many complaints from the paper's readers. The Guardian noted that a handful of other publications, from the Daily Mail Australia to the Daily Record in Scotland, also resorted to transphobic language, proving the extent to which transphobia permeates the global media landscape.

Words carry weight, even more so when circulated by a news empire like Murdoch's. When it comes to violence, there is no greater targeted group worldwide than trans women of color. Pedestrian, citing the Trans Violence Tracker, reports that while estimates put the trans community at not more than 1.5% of the world's population, its members are still "about 400 times more likely to be assaulted or murdered than the general population." In the United States, transgender women of color are at a disproportionately high risk of targeted violence, according to a report from the National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs.  

The Courier-Mail needs to do better. Claiming it "had no intention" of using offensive transphobic language is an abdication of it ethical journalistic responsibility. At no point in the editorial process does it appear that anyone had the sense or the decency to speak up.

How much do you trust the information in this article?

Marcie Bianco

Dr. Marcie Bianco is a Staff Writer at Mic, a Contributing Editor at Curve Magazine, and an adjunct associate professor at Hunter College. She has contributed to AfterEllen, Feministing, The Feminist Wire, The Huffington Post, Lambda Literary, XO Jane, and The Women’s Review of Books. She writes and lectures about ethics, from feminism to race relations. Her current writing projects include a manuscript about lesbian academic affairs and a collection of feminist essays.

MORE FROM

Kamala Harris' first signature bill attempts to end discriminatory "money bail" systems

The California senator introduced a bipartisan bill that would give millions in grants to states that individualize the pretrial release process.

People are sharing this video of John McCain defending Obama against scared white people in 2008

The video is meant to celebrate McCain's decency. But what really happened is more troubling.

GOP Senator defends hijab-wearing opponent from anti-Muslim abuse

Police are now escorting the Muslim Senate candidate to public events in response to the online abuse and hate mail.

Cults have a long history of exploiting black women

Black women have been exploited by cultic relationships for years. But this fact is often overlooked.

Anti-Muslim hate crimes spiked 91% within first half of 2017, new report says

2017 is on track to become one of the worst years for anti-Muslim hate crimes, according to a new report.

Prosecutor decides not to try Ray Tensing for third time in Sam DuBose's death

Twice already, jurors have not been able to agree whether Ray Tensing was guilty of murdering Sam DuBose.

Kamala Harris' first signature bill attempts to end discriminatory "money bail" systems

The California senator introduced a bipartisan bill that would give millions in grants to states that individualize the pretrial release process.

People are sharing this video of John McCain defending Obama against scared white people in 2008

The video is meant to celebrate McCain's decency. But what really happened is more troubling.

GOP Senator defends hijab-wearing opponent from anti-Muslim abuse

Police are now escorting the Muslim Senate candidate to public events in response to the online abuse and hate mail.

Cults have a long history of exploiting black women

Black women have been exploited by cultic relationships for years. But this fact is often overlooked.

Anti-Muslim hate crimes spiked 91% within first half of 2017, new report says

2017 is on track to become one of the worst years for anti-Muslim hate crimes, according to a new report.

Prosecutor decides not to try Ray Tensing for third time in Sam DuBose's death

Twice already, jurors have not been able to agree whether Ray Tensing was guilty of murdering Sam DuBose.