The U.K's Solution to Police Brutality Is Something the U.S. Would Never Consider

Source: AP
Source: AP

Fact: Police officers in America keep shooting — and killing — unarmed (and largely innocent) black men. 

Nearly every 28 hours the police shoot and kill an unarmed person, usually a black male (man, teenager or child), and they're doing so without repercussion. This has resulted in myriad calls to "demilitarize the police," but no one has stated the obvious. To "demilitarize the police," and to find a solution to police brutality, there is one clear solution: Disarm the police.

This isn't a new idea, yet Americans, especially American politicians, willingly avoid having this specific conversation. 

In 2012, 409 out of 410 "justifiable" killings by American police were caused by guns. Conversely, that year in the U.K., there was just one fatality. And in 2013, the Economist reports, "British police officers actually fired their weapons three times. The number of people fatally shot was zero."

The difference? American police carry guns. The police patrolling Britain, Scotland and Wales don't

Indeed, only roughly 5% of police in the U.K. are even authorized to carry guns. This nearly 200-year-old tradition was born of the mandate of the police to function as servants of the public rather than to the state. "In terms of the police being approachable, in terms of the public being the eyes and ears of the police, officers don't want to lose that," former police deputy assistant commissioner Brian Paddick said in an interview with the BBC.

Meanwhile, Japan has cut its firearm homicide rate to the low double and sometimes single digits due to restrictive gun laws. Japan's police force does carry guns, but only after submitting to a rigorous training process.

Faith in the police is exactly what America needs right now, especially within minority communities like the black community, which is disproportionately targeted and incarcerated by the criminal justice system. In the St. Louis metro area, which houses Ferguson, the murder of Mike Brown was tragic, but not unique. "A total of 39 people were fatally shot by police officers between 2003 and 2012," reports Mother Jones, citing statistics from the St. Louis Circuit Attorney's office, and "only one police officer has been indicted in such a case since 2000, and that officer was acquitted." It is not surprising given this evidence that some members of the black community say they increasingly feel mistrustful, even hunted

It's not as if the correlation between gun ownership and gun-related deaths hasn't been well-documented. As Charles M. Blow writes at the New York Times, "Among the [Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development] countries that the World Bank groups as 'high income,' America has the highest gun homicide rate, the highest number of guns per capita and the highest rate of deaths due to assault."


So why is nobody talking about it? Simply put, in America the issue of guns in America — no matter who owns them or what they are intended for — has become hopelessly entangled in the Second Amendment, to the degree that demilitarizing the police is currently considered a political impossibility, "Because the United States has a per capita gun ownership rate that is one of the highest in the Western world, the police must also be heavily militarized," notes the Washington Post.

This is, of course, a circular argument. That the Second Amendment predicates the "right of people to keep and bear arms" on the reality of the ability of a "well-regulated militia" to "secur[e] a free state" signals to gun control advocates, among others, that the amendment is outdated and in want of revision. It was, lest we forget, written (awkwardly and agrammatically) by white men of the 18th century, with 18th-century concerns, who were fighting for independence from England. 

Today, America is ostensibly a free state; no militia is needed, as Philip Gulley writes at Salon: "I cannot imagine any circumstance in which our government would urge us to arm ourselves in defense of our country. Our nation has outgrown its need for an armed citizenry. The disadvantages of widespread gun ownership far outweigh any perceived advantage ... Ask African-American residents of Ferguson, Missouri." 

And yet: The fact that we can't even consider this statistically proven solution is telling in itself. Taking away the guns won't in itself end police violence. Disarming the police would, of course, not eradicate all police brutality — we need only look to the recent case of Eric Garner, the black man who was killed by an New York police officer using a chokehold earlier this year — but it would be a large step in the right direction.

Regardless, the fact that in America we can't even begin a conversation on the topic without being shouted down by Second Amendment advocates touting patriotism and adherence to what they argue are the Founders' intentions regarding the Constitution is an outrage and a tragedy. If we want significant improvements in the criminal justice system, with the broader desire to eradicate systemic racism and sexism, then radical changes are needed at the institutional level. 

"To protect and to serve" should not require a gun. How many more men, women and children will die because of this inflexibility? Apparently, the answer is infinite.

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Marcie Bianco

Dr. Marcie Bianco is a Staff Writer at Mic, a Contributing Editor at Curve Magazine, and an adjunct associate professor at Hunter College. She has contributed to AfterEllen, Feministing, The Feminist Wire, The Huffington Post, Lambda Literary, XO Jane, and The Women’s Review of Books. She writes and lectures about ethics, from feminism to race relations. Her current writing projects include a manuscript about lesbian academic affairs and a collection of feminist essays.

MORE FROM

3 of the Central Park 5 men just received honorary high school diplomas

All of the men in the Central Park Five will receive the diplomas they were denied after their wrongful convictions as teenagers.

Another sign marking a scene from Emmett Till's murder has been vandalized

It's at least the second time in the past year a sign marking Till's murder has been vandalized.

South Carolina woman faces charges for ripping Confederate battle flag off driver's truck

The woman reportedly backed into the owner's truck, then fled the scene.

These amazing photos marking the end of Ramadan show how Muslims are celebrating Eid al-Fitr

Twitter users flooded social media with selfies and family snaps.

Philando Castile's family reaches $3 million settlement with Minnesota police

The settlement is the latest in a string of multi-million-dollar payouts that have followed police-involved deaths of African-Americans.

Chance the Rapper demands justice for Chicago at BET Awards, with an assist from Michelle Obama

Two high-profile Chicago natives call for action.

3 of the Central Park 5 men just received honorary high school diplomas

All of the men in the Central Park Five will receive the diplomas they were denied after their wrongful convictions as teenagers.

Another sign marking a scene from Emmett Till's murder has been vandalized

It's at least the second time in the past year a sign marking Till's murder has been vandalized.

South Carolina woman faces charges for ripping Confederate battle flag off driver's truck

The woman reportedly backed into the owner's truck, then fled the scene.

These amazing photos marking the end of Ramadan show how Muslims are celebrating Eid al-Fitr

Twitter users flooded social media with selfies and family snaps.

Philando Castile's family reaches $3 million settlement with Minnesota police

The settlement is the latest in a string of multi-million-dollar payouts that have followed police-involved deaths of African-Americans.

Chance the Rapper demands justice for Chicago at BET Awards, with an assist from Michelle Obama

Two high-profile Chicago natives call for action.