How Pardoning America's Torture Architects Could Prevent More Torture

Source: Getty Images
Source: Getty Images

The Senate Intelligence Committee released Tuesday its long-awaited report on the U.S. government's use of torture in the aftermath of 9/11. It's rife with stories of a variety of shocking torture techniques, from mock executions to waterboarding and to submitting subjects to hypothermia-inducing conditions that were fatal in at least one instance.

The American Civil Liberties Union's executive director, Anthony D. Romero, argued in the New York Times that this may be the last opportunity the country has to hold the perpetrators of the torture regime accountable. And he has an interesting proposal: President Barack Obama should pre-emptively pardon members of the Bush administration who were responsible for the torture program.

At first blush this sounds like the opposite of holding someone responsible, but it may be the best hope of preventing future misconduct. Romero argues that pardoning those officials responsible would "make clear that crimes were committed; that the individuals who authorized and committed torture were indeed criminals; and that future architects and perpetrators of torture should beware." While too much time has elapsed for a serious prosecution, Obama could formally issue pardons of the architects of the torture regime to establish their illegality for future generations.

Under the Bush administration, the legal foundation and logistical coordination of torture was overseen at the highest levels of government, and without any formal recognition of their wrongdoing, the practices Obama repudiated when he came into office is more likely to resurface in the future. Romero contends that if greater measures aren't taken, we're leaving a dangerous door open:

The president leaves open the very real possibility that officials will resurrect the torture policies in the future. Indeed, many former CIA and other government officials continue to insist that waterboarding and other forms of torture were lawful. Were our military to capture a senior leader of the Islamic State who was believed to have valuable information, some members of Congress would no doubt demand that our interrogators use precisely the barbaric and illegal methods that the Obama administration has disavowed.

Of course, this was the case when Obama took office in 2009, and many advocates — including the ACLU — pressed upon him to prosecute the Bush administration, or at least set up some kind of truth and reconciliation commission to safeguard against this potential slide back into barbarism. Obama, ever the conflict-averse technocrat, declined to take such measures.  

But Romero's case for a pardon offers a compelling middle ground. Given Obama's non-confrontational disposition and the fact that the window of time for prosecuting former officials has mostly closed, he could instead issue a pardon. This manages to establish formal legal precedent and brand Bush and his top officials as criminals, all without prosecution. Pre-emptive pardoning has historical precedent: Abraham Lincoln and Andrew Johnson did it for Confederate soldiers as a gesture of reconciliation after the Civil War; Gerald Ford pardoned Richard Nixon for the Watergate crimes.

A pardon by Obama could be accomplished with the stroke of a pen and will firmly establish torture as criminal and morally heinous. It won't compensate for past sins, but it can make it less likely they're committed in the future.

This post has been updated.

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Zeeshan Aleem

Zeeshan is a senior staff writer at Mic, covering public policy and national politics. He is based in New York and can be reached at zeeshan@mic.com.

MORE FROM

"No religion" is now Australia's most popular religious affiliation

The segment of Australia's population marking "no religion" is growing quickly.

Global ransomware hack hits infrastructure targets across Europe

Targets include Russia's biggest oil company, Ukraine's largest airport and its state power company.

France convenes youngest, most diverse Parliament in its history. Is this the future of Europe?

Thanks to Emmanuel Macron's newly formed party, the French government is more diverse than ever before.

Kremlin slams White House's warning of potential chemical attack in Syria

The U.S. and Russia continue to spar over Syria.

EU slaps Google with a record 2.42 billion euro fine

The tech giant has a hefty fine in its future.

Detroit judge halts deportation of 1,400 Iraqi nationals living in US

Many of the Iraqis are Chaldean Christians who reportedly voted for Trump.

"No religion" is now Australia's most popular religious affiliation

The segment of Australia's population marking "no religion" is growing quickly.

Global ransomware hack hits infrastructure targets across Europe

Targets include Russia's biggest oil company, Ukraine's largest airport and its state power company.

France convenes youngest, most diverse Parliament in its history. Is this the future of Europe?

Thanks to Emmanuel Macron's newly formed party, the French government is more diverse than ever before.

Kremlin slams White House's warning of potential chemical attack in Syria

The U.S. and Russia continue to spar over Syria.

EU slaps Google with a record 2.42 billion euro fine

The tech giant has a hefty fine in its future.

Detroit judge halts deportation of 1,400 Iraqi nationals living in US

Many of the Iraqis are Chaldean Christians who reportedly voted for Trump.