Do Plus-Size Models Send a Bad Message About Weight? Study Explores Complicated Question

"This bitch looks like 10 packs of chewed bubblegum stuffed in a finger cot. Think that's sexy and admirable? Fine, die slowly on your own goddamned time."

Comments like the one above, which was reportedly left on a photo of size-22 model Tess Holliday, are undoubtedly harsh. But they reflect a counterpoint to culture's growing conversation about body positivity, specifically representation of "plus-size" bodies. For every few ads that promote curvier women, there tend to be a few responses that argue that "promoting obesity" or encouraging unhealthy habits is dangerous.

Is that true? And if so, what's the solution? A new study entitled "The (Ironic) Dove Effect: Usage of Acceptance Cues for Larger Body Types Increases Unhealthy Behaviors," found that using models with larger bodies can, in fact, have an adverse effect. In five experiments, each with female subjects, "cues suggesting the acceptance of larger body types resulted in greater intended or actual consumption of food and a reduced motivation to engage in a healthier lifestyle," the study states.

But stigmatizing larger bodies isn't helpful for viewers either. In fact, the researchers find, there is damage to be had from any advertising that focuses explicitly on body size — skinny or fat, positive or negative — by "increasing the amount of thought consumers put into their appearance and heightening body anxiety."

Two of the more well-known, body-positive ad campaigns: Lane Bryant's #PlusIsEqual and Dove's 11-year-old Real Beauty campaign.
Source: 
Lane Bryant/Dove

The study: Professors Pei-Shiuan Lin of California State University, Los Angeles, and Brent McFerran of Simon Fraser University in Vancouver conducted five experiments, each to gauge viewers' reactions and behaviors after viewing "cues" that promoted larger bodies. 

One experiment involved showing participants three ads for a fake clothing store, each one featuring the same overweight model but with different taglines: "For Normal Women, "For Plus Size Women" or "For Women." Viewing the "For Normal Women" ad, which signaled acceptance of larger bodies, "increased people's tendency to choose less healthy food items and decreased their motivation to be in better shape," the researchers found.

Another experiment showed participants ads for a gym, including a version that featured an overweight model with the tagline "For Real Women," a version with the overweight model with the tagline "Time to Slim Down," one with a thin model and the tagline "For Real Women" and a fourth with a thin model with the tagline "Time to Slim Down." Respondents then answered questionnaires about their motivation to exercise, judgment of other bodies and satisfaction with their bodies.

The most noteworthy takeaway? "While accepting a larger-bodied figure decreased motivation (thus replicating our earlier results), accepting a thin-bodied figure did not increase motivation," the study notes.

Dear Kate's "Perfect Body" campaign, 2014
Source: 
Dear Kate

A fixation on body sizes, big and small: The finding that acceptance of larger bodies, a la Dove's Real Beauty campaign (which lends the study its title), can decrease motivation to exercise or eat well may be a troubling one, particularly among body-positivity advocates. 

But one of the other crucial findings, the researchers said, is the damage that any body-conscious advertising can have. 

"It is very important for us to emphasize that our work is in no way saying that ads that shame larger body types or promote overly thin/unrealistic body types should be used, as they can also have negative effects on consumers, " Professor Pei-Shiuan Lin told Mic, something that's been documented in past studies

"It may be a bad idea for marketers to make people's body sizes/types the main focus in their communications."

Instead of emphasizing acceptance or stigmatizing, Lin said, the best choice for advertisers may be to de-emphasize body size entirely.

"It may not be a good idea for them to put a value judgment on 'any' body type (i.e., stating a body type as 'good,' 'bad,' 'acceptable,' 'unacceptable,' 'real,' 'normal,' etc)," Lin said. "It may also be a bad idea for marketers to make people's body sizes/types the main focus in their communications, as bringing these issues to 'top of mind' could have negative implications."

That may not be where body positivity as a movement is right now, where promoting acceptance of bigger bodies and highlighting diverse figures is seen as the most praise-worthy move (and something Mic has praised in the past) in ads, store windows and magazine covers. But total acceptance, ultimately, means getting to a place where we don't feel the need to assert the acceptability of curvier bodies — so we can consume fashion ads and maybe think about something other than our figures for a change.

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Ellie Krupnick

Ellie is Mic's editorial director of lifestyle. A former style and fashion editor for The Huffington Post, her writing has also appeared in Women's Wear Daily, HarpersBazaar.com and the Twitter feeds of British royal fans everywhere.

MORE FROM

8 of the biggest moments from the 48th NYC LGBT Pride March

The biggest Pride event in the world was a sight to behold.

Movement for Black Lives activists disrupt Minneapolis Pride to protest Philando Castile verdict

Protesters reportedly held signs with messages like "No KKKops at Pride."

Protesters reportedly arrested near NYC's Stonewall Inn, Pride March endpoint

The reason for the arrests were not immediately known.

Marchers arrested in Istanbul as Pride parade continues despite cancellation

The organizers' decision to move forward with the previously cancelled march led to clashes with police.

Car slams into Eid celebrants in UK, injuring 6; police say terrorism isn't suspected

Police say they believe an Eid celebrant was behind the wheel of the car that injured six outside a mosque.

Oil truck explodes in Pakistan, killing at least 153

The deadly fire broke out as residents rushed to collect the leaking oil from the overturned tanker.

8 of the biggest moments from the 48th NYC LGBT Pride March

The biggest Pride event in the world was a sight to behold.

Movement for Black Lives activists disrupt Minneapolis Pride to protest Philando Castile verdict

Protesters reportedly held signs with messages like "No KKKops at Pride."

Protesters reportedly arrested near NYC's Stonewall Inn, Pride March endpoint

The reason for the arrests were not immediately known.

Marchers arrested in Istanbul as Pride parade continues despite cancellation

The organizers' decision to move forward with the previously cancelled march led to clashes with police.

Car slams into Eid celebrants in UK, injuring 6; police say terrorism isn't suspected

Police say they believe an Eid celebrant was behind the wheel of the car that injured six outside a mosque.

Oil truck explodes in Pakistan, killing at least 153

The deadly fire broke out as residents rushed to collect the leaking oil from the overturned tanker.