Judge Marvin Zuker Slams Victim Blaming With a Powerful Verdict in a Sexual Assault Case

Source: Andrey Bermakin/Shutterstock

It's horrifyingly common to see lawyers and judges blame sexual assault victims. Take, for instance, the notorious case of Montana Judge G. Todd Baugh, who said a teenage rape victim was "older than her chronological age" and was "as much in control of the situation" as her adult rapist, according to NBC News

But in the past few weeks, two judges have issued strong statements in sexual assault cases that make it clear the attackers, and they alone, are responsible for the crimes they commit. 

On July 21 in Toronto, Ontario Court Justice Marvin Zuker delivered a verdict on a rape case involving students at York University. The Guardian reported his decision included the following statement: "The myths of rape should be dispelled once and for all. It doesn't matter if the victim was drinking, out at night alone, sexually exploited, on a date with the perpetrator or how the victim was dressed. No one asks to be raped." 

The judge literally underlined the last sentence of his statement.

The survivor herself, Mandi Gray, issued an equally strong statement on the verdict on her personal Facebook page. In her post, she wrote she is "tired of people talking to me like I won some sort of rape lottery because the legal system did what it is supposed to."

"I am [a] white, heterosexual woman in my late 20s with a graduate-level education and an in-depth knowledge of the legal system," she wrote on Facebook, later adding, "my numerous and intersecting privileges cannot be ignored and therefore my experience of sexual assault and the legal system is atypical."

Zuker's statement echoes that of another recent Canadian case, in which Alberta Justice Juliana Topolniski overturned a lower court's ruling on appeal to acquit an underage defendant's sexual assault charge. Earlier this year, a youth court judge determined the defendant was not guilty because the victim's objections were "unclear," according to legal records cited by Topolniski.

In her statement, Topolniski lambasted the lower court's ruling, issuing a powerful statement about the importance of consent in the process. 

"Consent means 'yes.' The word 'no' does not mean 'yes.' The word 'no' coupled with fending off an attacker with a water bottle does not mean 'yes.' There is nothing ambiguous about it. Even if the situation was as the trial judge found 'at best ambiguous,' that is not 'yes,'" Topolniski wrote. 

American justice system, take note. Canada is showing us how it's done. 

Read more:
• Brock Turner's Lawyer Tried to Blame the Victim's Drinking During the Stanford Rape Trial
• Comedian Alice Brine's Viral Facebook Post Perfectly Sums Up How Dumb Victim Blaming Is
• A Michigan City Attorney Called an Alleged Rape Victim a "Whore" in an Email

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

MORE FROM

This small Ohio town might stop treating heroin overdoses to save the city money

"People will die. It's plain and simple."

Here's what New York's first official LGBTQ monument will look like

Here's our first look at New York's new monument to LGBT communities.

How will Trump's travel ban be enforced? Here's what the Supreme Court's decision really means.

The Supreme Court's order prevents most of the ban from taking effect before the case is heard, with limited exceptions.

Tick saliva could be the key to fighting a dangerous heart condition

Ticks could hold the secret to treating this heart condition.

CNN retraction and undercover video feeds into pro-Trump media's "fake news" claims

The release of a secretly recorded video of a CNN producer on Tuesday has amplified criticism.

Lockdown lifted at Alabama military post after reports of "possible active shooter"

The Redstone Arsenal was briefly on lockdown Tuesday.

This small Ohio town might stop treating heroin overdoses to save the city money

"People will die. It's plain and simple."

Here's what New York's first official LGBTQ monument will look like

Here's our first look at New York's new monument to LGBT communities.

How will Trump's travel ban be enforced? Here's what the Supreme Court's decision really means.

The Supreme Court's order prevents most of the ban from taking effect before the case is heard, with limited exceptions.

Tick saliva could be the key to fighting a dangerous heart condition

Ticks could hold the secret to treating this heart condition.

CNN retraction and undercover video feeds into pro-Trump media's "fake news" claims

The release of a secretly recorded video of a CNN producer on Tuesday has amplified criticism.

Lockdown lifted at Alabama military post after reports of "possible active shooter"

The Redstone Arsenal was briefly on lockdown Tuesday.