Unemployed husbands, not financial problems, are most likely to break up marriages

Unemployed husbands, not financial problems, are most likely to break up marriages
Source: Shutterstock
Source: Shutterstock

Fighting about chores? Money woes? It could be worse.

Turns out that the biggest factor correlated with straight couples getting divorced is neither financial problems nor the division of domestic work: It is whether the man in the relationship is employed, a new Harvard University study shows.

Researchers looked at more than 6,000 marriages stretching from 1968 to 2013, to see how gender dynamics have changed since women began entering the workforce in greater numbers.

The authors wrote: 

"...Wives' employment is not associated with the risk of divorce, while husbands' lack of full-time employment remains associated with marital instability ... changes in the gender structure may not have proceeded evenly for men and women; fulfillment of the male-breadwinner role appears to be equally or more strongly associated with marital stability."

In other words, the most influential variable increasing the likelihood of divorce was when the husband was out of a job, suggesting men have not socially adapted to the idea of not being a breadwinner.

"Expectations of wives' homemaking may have eroded, but the husband breadwinner norm persists," the authors wrote.

The findings lend credence to comments President Barack Obama has made about the link between men's employment and happy family life.

"When men don't have work, when they don't feel good about being able to support their families, then often they detach themselves," he said in an interview with Parade in 2014. "The children then don't have a male presence in the home."

There are a few caveats, and the main one is that the study didn't really look at stay-at-home dads who choose to take care of the kids: Most of the unemployed husbands weren't in that position by choice.

Then again, there aren't a lot of stay-at-home dads yet to study: One Pew report shows that the proportion of stay-at-home dads doubled between 1989 and 2012, reaching nearly 2 million — which is only 7% of the total dad count.

Still, the numbers show there is a small, growing group of men who are perfectly happy to ditch the breadwinner role. 

Part of the trend has to do with expectations. The Pew study also found that more than half of Americans think that children are better off when the mom stays home, a number that plummets to 8% when asked the same about dads. 

A new study has some alarming conclusions the strain placed on marriages when husbands aren't the breadwinner.
Source: 
Mel Evans/AP

While it might be heartening to some to see more stay-at-home dads trying to break the mold, the Harvard study shows straight marriages are unfortunately still bound by traditional gender roles — particularly when the man isn't the one bringing home the bacon. 

One more for the #masculinitysofragile files. 

Read more: 
• The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Wants Debt Collectors to Stop Harassing You
• Want to Buy a House or Apartment? How to Know If You Can Actually Afford a Home
• Best Jobs for High Pay: Here Are 7 Positions in Fields With Growing Wages

How much do you trust the information in this article?

James Dennin

James is a staff writer covering money and millennials. Send your tips and your money problems to jdennin@mic.com.

MORE FROM

The 7 best deals in America

If you want to stretch your dollar to its maximum possible extent, check out these seven great deals.

What to know about Uber's $15 forgotten item fee

Uber alternatives are out there, which won't charge you a fee if you left behind or forgot something in the car — and need it back from the driver.

Tips that pay off: Figure out what to do with your life

Not sure what really makes you tick? Here's how to step back and customize the perfect career plan for yourself.

Can you save money on a home by buying a foreclosure? 5 things to know

Real estate-owned properties — those in foreclosure — can sell for 20% below market value. But proceed with caution, as many require extensive repairs that add to their total cost.

7 unconscious mistakes that make you waste money on food

Save money by becoming more self aware; stop sabotaging your food budget, and get back on track.

7 slick moves to save big bucks on back-to-school costs

Planning to spend hundreds on back-to-school costs? Follow these simple tips and tricks to keep more money in your pocket.

The 7 best deals in America

If you want to stretch your dollar to its maximum possible extent, check out these seven great deals.

What to know about Uber's $15 forgotten item fee

Uber alternatives are out there, which won't charge you a fee if you left behind or forgot something in the car — and need it back from the driver.

Tips that pay off: Figure out what to do with your life

Not sure what really makes you tick? Here's how to step back and customize the perfect career plan for yourself.

Can you save money on a home by buying a foreclosure? 5 things to know

Real estate-owned properties — those in foreclosure — can sell for 20% below market value. But proceed with caution, as many require extensive repairs that add to their total cost.

7 unconscious mistakes that make you waste money on food

Save money by becoming more self aware; stop sabotaging your food budget, and get back on track.

7 slick moves to save big bucks on back-to-school costs

Planning to spend hundreds on back-to-school costs? Follow these simple tips and tricks to keep more money in your pocket.