Here's Why We Should End the #AllLivesMatter Debate Once and for All

Here's Why We Should End the #AllLivesMatter Debate Once and for All
Source: Getty Images
Source: Getty Images

Since the inception of #BlackLivesMatter, critics have often responded by using a loaded retort: #AllLivesMatter, they say. The turn of phrase is a more polite way of drowning out a rallying cry affirming black life than one offering the politically-incorrect assertion that black lives don't matter at all.

#AllLivesMatter is a rhetorical flip that suggests particular issues impacting black people — like over-policing, hyper criminalization and economic disenfranchisement  — aren't exceptional when, in fact, they are. It is also a less overt way of insinuating the lives of white people matter, too. But the creators of #BlackLivesMatter were clear about the intent of the hashtag when it was created. It was never intended to mean black people, and black issues, matter more, but that black people, and the issues impacting black lives, haven't mattered throughout the history of the U.S. 

"When we say Black Lives Matter, we are talking about the ways in which black people are deprived of our basic human rights and dignity," Alicia Garza, co-creator of #BlackLivesMatter, wrote at The Feminist Wire. "It is an acknowledgement black poverty and genocide is state violence. It is an acknowledgment that 1 million black people are locked in cages in this country — one half of all people in prisons or jails — is an act of state violence. It is an acknowledgment that black women continue to bear the burden of a relentless assault on our children and our families and that assault is an act of state violence."

Despite Garza's explanation, the debate continues. But the #AllLivesMatter vs. #BlackLivesMatter debate is one not worth having. Those who proclaim #AllLivesMatter are demonstrating their lack of desire to listen to and empathize with the conditions impacting black lives. Instead, they choose to deflect attention away from the issues the movement for black lives has brought to the fore.

Read more:
These 'Arthur' Memes Perfectly Nail How We Talk About Race in the United States
Here's the Perfect Explanation for Why White People Need to Stop Saying #AllLivesMatter
Jennifer Lopez Tweets #AllLivesMatter, Deletes It, But Not Before Twitter Clapped Back

How much do you trust the information in this article?

Darnell L. Moore

Darnell L. Moore is a Senior Editor and Senior Correspondent at Mic. He is also co-managing editor of The Feminist Wire and Writer-in-Residence at the Center on African American Religion, Sexual Politics and Social Justice at Columbia University.

MORE FROM

Warrant suggests Justine Damond may have slapped police cruiser before she was fatally shot

The officers involved in the shooting remain on paid administrative leave.

House passes new sanctions against Russia by an enormous margin

The bill also places limits on Trump’s power to ease or end penalties against Russia.

Paul Manafort is meeting with Senate investigators. Here’s what we know about his Russia ties.

Paul Manafort has Russia links dating back more than 10 years.

Yes, Donald Trump can fire Robert Mueller. Here’s how he can do it.

It's a complicated process, and it could get messy, but he can do it.

Charlie Gard’s parents say they want to take their son home to die

The parents are returning to court to fight for their right to take their son home.

Vatican shuts off historic fountains in the midst of devastating drought

Officials say it's the first time they can recall ever shutting off the Vatican's fountains.

Warrant suggests Justine Damond may have slapped police cruiser before she was fatally shot

The officers involved in the shooting remain on paid administrative leave.

House passes new sanctions against Russia by an enormous margin

The bill also places limits on Trump’s power to ease or end penalties against Russia.

Paul Manafort is meeting with Senate investigators. Here’s what we know about his Russia ties.

Paul Manafort has Russia links dating back more than 10 years.

Yes, Donald Trump can fire Robert Mueller. Here’s how he can do it.

It's a complicated process, and it could get messy, but he can do it.

Charlie Gard’s parents say they want to take their son home to die

The parents are returning to court to fight for their right to take their son home.

Vatican shuts off historic fountains in the midst of devastating drought

Officials say it's the first time they can recall ever shutting off the Vatican's fountains.