Professional investors who grew up poor are more talented, but less likely to get promoted

Professional investors who grew up poor are more talented, but less likely to get promoted
Source: Shutterstock
Source: Shutterstock

The spawn of rich families may not — surprise, surprise — be that great at managing money, according to a new working paper published by the National Bureau of Economic Research. 

Using data from investment research company Morningstar, study authors Oleg Chuprinin and Denis Sosyura analyzed the performance of hundreds of individual managers of active U.S. mutual funds that held at least $10 million in assets at some point between 1975 and 2012. Funds managed by teams were excluded.

The researchers found that "managers from poor families deliver higher alphas than managers from rich families," meaning investors from modest beginnings were actually more likely to beat broad benchmarks — and make money for their clients.

A lot more money, in fact. Fund managers who were born in the top fifth of household incomes underperformed those in the bottom fifth by more than 2% annually. 

While 2% might seem like a small number, that adds up to a lot of moolah over time: Let's say, for example, you have $10,000 invested in a retirement account. In just one year, 2% of that is $200 lost. Once you're older and your balance is more like $500,000, 2% is a whopping $10,000. And that doesn't even account for interest.

There's a fairly intuitive reason for the NBER paper's findings. "Because individuals from less privileged backgrounds have much higher barriers to entry into prestigious positions, only the most skilled types can exceed these thresholds," the study's authors wrote.  

Not only must managers of less wealthy origins work harder to get jobs, they aren't done leaping hurdles once they're hired: Their peers who were born rich were more also likely to get promoted, the authors found.

A rich upbringing will give you a leg up on Wall Street, but it might make you worse at your job.
Source: 
Kena Betancur/Getty Images

To come to their conclusions, Chuprinin and Sosyura compiled personal histories of money managers by reading through census records and employment and education histories, as well as records available on Ancestry.com.

Once they'd accounted for duplicates, errors, people born overseas and those in the military, the authors were left with a group 267 U.S. managers and their family histories.

The researchers believe that these findings could have implications far beyond finance, and that "social status at birth may serve as an important signal of quality in other industries," as well.

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

James Dennin

James is a staff writer covering money and millennials. Send your tips and your money problems to jdennin@mic.com.

MORE FROM

9 smart things to buy as an investment in your future

From stocks to cryptocurrencies, here are 9 ideas for ways to invest extra cash to build your wealth.

How to save an easy $10 every single day

Saving just $10 a day amounts to thousands of extra dollars you can put toward important financial goals at the end of the year.

Tips that pay off: Starting a business — the successful way

Turn your dream startup into reality in five simple steps.

5 genius things you should do with $1,000 right now

What should you do with extra money? Here are some clever ways to invest your cash today.

Owed money from a class action settlement? How to find out — and get your cash.

Owed a payout from a company because of a class-action lawsuit? Here are 5 things to know about getting the cash you deserve.

How much you should actually spend on wedding gifts

This is what is normal — and polite — to pay for a wedding present.

9 smart things to buy as an investment in your future

From stocks to cryptocurrencies, here are 9 ideas for ways to invest extra cash to build your wealth.

How to save an easy $10 every single day

Saving just $10 a day amounts to thousands of extra dollars you can put toward important financial goals at the end of the year.

Tips that pay off: Starting a business — the successful way

Turn your dream startup into reality in five simple steps.

5 genius things you should do with $1,000 right now

What should you do with extra money? Here are some clever ways to invest your cash today.

Owed money from a class action settlement? How to find out — and get your cash.

Owed a payout from a company because of a class-action lawsuit? Here are 5 things to know about getting the cash you deserve.

How much you should actually spend on wedding gifts

This is what is normal — and polite — to pay for a wedding present.