The Fallacy of Sending Women to the "Back of the Bus"

Egypt is just one of many countries that offer voluntary segregation on their public transportation systems. Fifteen countries in total have instituted some sort of “woman’s only” section in public transportation, including Japan, India, Indonesia, Guatemala, Brazil, the UAE, and soon South Korea. Each case is unique in its circumstances, given the various social factors and laws that surround the protection of women outside the transports. But the question remains, is such social segregation necessary?

If we focus on the long-term, the answer is a resounding “no.”

The reasoning behind the implementation of “women’s only” sections on metros and other public transport appears appropriate on the surface. Sexual harassment toward women in these cities is rampant. For Cairo, the often cited figure for harassment is based on a 2008 Egyptian Center for Women’s Rights Report that stated 83% of local women and 98% of foreign women reported sexual harassment, with 62% of men admitting that they had sexually harassed a woman at some point. Creating a section for women on public transport can immediately help stem the problem of unwanted attention and provocation. It can also encourage women who may have been dissuaded from taking public transport in the past to become more active in the labor and education sectors, as they are dependent on the males in the household for transport. Indeed, women’s initial reactions towards these sections have been positive, especially since this service is optional.

Yet while these segregated cars are in theory optional, once instituted, women are expected to use them and they therefore become, in practice, the only method of transport available to women. Existence of one option negates the other in this case, meaning that the expectation coupled with the intrinsic and extrinsic pressures to use such a section practically forces a woman to choose the women’s section. Surely there were and are brave women who still choose the unisex sections, but at what point in time will those women – under increasing leers and stares, dwindling numbers of their own sex, and inevitable worsening harassment conditions – continue to do so?

Other issues arise as well. The construction of these women-only cars may perpetuate the perception that women inherently need to be singled out, protected, and isolated. In essence, creating this kind of divide may facilitate the idea, real or imagined, that division is necessary. As Muna Kahn astutely points out, as soon as we have established that the best method to protect women is to segregate and isolate them from deeply inherent patriarchal problems of a society, where do we draw the line? How long until all crowded, public urban spaces become the target for such segregation?

Gender segregated public transportation is problematic because a physical partition creates a long-term psychological one. The cities that have opted for this measure should take notice that other, more effective options exist to protect women and curtail patriarchy, many of which fall within the state’s legislative powers. A more adequate solution to the problem would seemingly be to raise awareness through gender friendly grassroots movements and civil society, anti-harassment campaigns, and beefed up security on public transport systems. Governments could also introduce gender egalitarian legislation and take a harder stance through punitive action on offenders.

There is no better display of the corrosiveness of a society than its treatment of women within the home, within the public sphere, and at the political level, and increasingly Egypt and the rest are failing all three tests.

Instead of solving the problem, these states are just masking a much deeper, long-term one. Are Cairo and others slowly creating another “back of the bus”?

Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Aleksandar Deejay

I graduated with an MA in International Relations from the American University in Paris and a BA in International Affairs from the University of South Florida. Currently I'm a PhD candidate at the University of Melbourne in the social and political sciences department. My master's thesis involved the progression of women's social movements in post-Mubarak Egypt. I've worked in Washington DC on race relations and women's rights issues. My interests and most of my writings are on cosmopolitanism; global civil society, power, and governance; contentious movements, especially transnational ones;the role of technology in international relations practice and theory; and human rights, with an emphasis on gender. My regional knowledge is mostly within the US, MENA, and Central Asia. My regional weaknesses include South America and Sub-Saharan Africa, though I'm always willing to learn more about these regions. I'm currently beginning my Arabic studies, and would like to perfect my French, so any help there is truly appreciated. I'm always in the mood for discussion or debate, but be warned I can be pretty passionate about certain points! Being some sort of liberal, cosmopolitan, secular humanist I guess does that to you :)

MORE FROM

Hillary Clinton says Republicans will be the "death party" if they pass health care bill

Hillary Clinton spoke out against the Republican's proposed bill on Twitter.

It's time to redefine the clitoris, according to sex education experts

"Words matter. They shape and mold our ideas and beliefs about our purpose, our bodies, our self-worth and our place in the world around us."

Al-Jazeera becomes a target amid Qatar diplomatic crisis

Gulf states are demanding the broadcaster be shut down.

5 blocks of London apartments to be evacuated over potentially flammable cladding

800 North London apartments will be evacuated following a fire inspection that turned up evidence that the buildings could be unsafe.

Tomi Lahren wants to rally women to her side after criticizing feminists and "pro-choicers"

"My view on abortion is not black-and-white," Lahren said.

These 5 states are drafting laws to limit protests on college campuses

The legislation is intended to protect free speech on campus.

Hillary Clinton says Republicans will be the "death party" if they pass health care bill

Hillary Clinton spoke out against the Republican's proposed bill on Twitter.

It's time to redefine the clitoris, according to sex education experts

"Words matter. They shape and mold our ideas and beliefs about our purpose, our bodies, our self-worth and our place in the world around us."

Al-Jazeera becomes a target amid Qatar diplomatic crisis

Gulf states are demanding the broadcaster be shut down.

5 blocks of London apartments to be evacuated over potentially flammable cladding

800 North London apartments will be evacuated following a fire inspection that turned up evidence that the buildings could be unsafe.

Tomi Lahren wants to rally women to her side after criticizing feminists and "pro-choicers"

"My view on abortion is not black-and-white," Lahren said.

These 5 states are drafting laws to limit protests on college campuses

The legislation is intended to protect free speech on campus.