Saif Al Islam Gaddafi on Trial: The International Criminal Court Has No Business Usurping the Government of Libya

The International Criminal Court (ICC) has recently heard opposing arguments on issues surrounding the Court’s indictment of Saif Al Islam Gaddafi, son of former Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi; and Colonel Abdullah Al-Senussi, former head of the Libyan Military Intelligence. Gaddafi and Al-Senussi are accused of two counts of crimes against humanity. The bone of contention between the ICC and Libya is a question of jurisdiction — who should try the two accused? The answer lies at the heart of the Rome Statute, and for many International Law Scholars, the matter should not even have reached a hearing before the Court. 

At the heart of the Rome Statute, which established the ICC, is the Principle of Complementarity. Paragraph 10 of the preamble and Article I of the Rome State emphasize that the ICC shall be complementary to national criminal jurisdictions. It is very clear that preliminary jurisdiction over the accused falls within the national criminal jurisdiction of Libya. Most international lawyers are very surprised, then, that the ICC is consistently trying to usurp jurisdiction from a sovereign state.  

Article 17 of the Rome Statute states that the Court shall declare a case inadmissible when the case “is being investigated or prosecuted by a state which has jurisdiction over it,” and “unless the state is unwilling or unable genuinely to carry out the investigation or prosecution,” the Court has no business predetermining the strength of the tribunals of sovereign nations. 

Libya has emphasized its willingness to investigate and prosecute the accused for crimes committed at home, and the ICC is insistently trying to usurp the case. The ICC is determined to put the Libyan judicial system on trial even before the country has a chance of proving its commitment to democracy and justice. It makes a bad precedent that an international institution such as the ICC is basically trying to predetermine the ability of a sovereign nation to administer justice when there are no facts to doubt that the accused will not have a fair trial in Libya. 

In addition to the principle of complementarity, criminal justice and pragmatism requires the accused to face the people of Libya. The Gaddafi regime was overthrown in a popular revolt and the people of the country deserve a summation to their revolution by having those responsible put on trial at home.  What use does it serve the Libyan people to ship their accused to The Hague when their national tribunal assures us that it is capable and willing to render justice both for the accused and the people of Libya? There may be doubts, but the ICC has no business usurping Libyan national criminal process. The Court should dismiss the case and allow the Libyan judicial system to proceed.

How much do you trust the information in this article?

Joseph Kaifala

Joseph Ben Kaifala is founder of the Jeneba Project Inc. and co-founder of the Sierra Leone Memory Project. He was born in Sierra Leone and spent his early childhood in Liberia and Guinea. He later moved to Norway where he studied for the International Baccalaureate (IB) at the Red Cross Nordic United World College before enrolling at Skidmore College in New York. Joseph was an International Affairs & French Major, with a minor in Law & Society. Joseph is also a Human Rights activist, a Rastafarian, and a votary of ahimsa. He speaks six languages. Joseph has served as a Davis United World College Fellow at the James Martin Center for Nonproliferation Studies; a Humanity In Action Senior Fellow; and a Tom Lantos-HIA US Congressional Fellow. He holds a Master’s degree in International Relations from Syracuse University, a Diploma in Intercultural Encounters from the Helsinki Summer School, and a Certificate in Professional French administered by the French Chamber of Commerce. Joseph was an Applied Human Rights Fellow at Vermont Law School, where he completed his JD and Certificate in International & Comparative Law. He is recipient of the Skidmore College Palamountain Prose Award, Skidmore College Thoroughbred Award, and Vermont Law School (SBA) Student Pro Bono Award. Joseph is a 2013-2014 American Society of International Law Helton Fellow. He served as Justice of the Arthur Chapter of Phi Alpha Delta Law Fraternity International.

MORE FROM

What does Sean Spicer’s resignation mean for the rest of Trump’s inner circle?

Many are already wondering if Spicer's departure could portend more shakeups to come.

How the messy New York City subways are hurting vulnerable New Yorkers the most

The New York subway system is a mess — and here's who's suffering the most.

Is Sean Spicer the shortest-serving White House press secretary in history?

Spicer served just six months as press secretary — there are some cabinet members in White House history who have served mere days.

5 stories from this week that aren't about OJ Simpson or Sean Spicer

The White House will be forced to release logs from Mar-a-Lago, and Democrats finally have an agenda.

According to Anthony Scaramucci’s Twitter, he believes in climate change and voted for Barack Obama

He also supports same-sex marriage. And abortion rights.

Trump is reportedly looking into pardoning himself. Here’s why that could backfire.

Can the president really pardon himself?

What does Sean Spicer’s resignation mean for the rest of Trump’s inner circle?

Many are already wondering if Spicer's departure could portend more shakeups to come.

How the messy New York City subways are hurting vulnerable New Yorkers the most

The New York subway system is a mess — and here's who's suffering the most.

Is Sean Spicer the shortest-serving White House press secretary in history?

Spicer served just six months as press secretary — there are some cabinet members in White House history who have served mere days.

5 stories from this week that aren't about OJ Simpson or Sean Spicer

The White House will be forced to release logs from Mar-a-Lago, and Democrats finally have an agenda.

According to Anthony Scaramucci’s Twitter, he believes in climate change and voted for Barack Obama

He also supports same-sex marriage. And abortion rights.

Trump is reportedly looking into pardoning himself. Here’s why that could backfire.

Can the president really pardon himself?