How Trump could destroy global order by refusing to defend the Baltics

 How Trump could destroy global order by refusing to defend the Baltics
President-elect Donald Trump speaks during his first news conference as president-elect.
Source: Seth Wenig/AP
President-elect Donald Trump speaks during his first news conference as president-elect.
Source: Seth Wenig/AP

Over the last decade, the United States has fought insurgencies in both Afghanistan and Iraq and developed a lot of skill in counterinsurgency. The small Baltic state of Estonia, on the other hand, is training its citizens in insurgency. It is doing this because it is afraid of a Russian invasion and occupation, and with good reason. Russia has carried out cyberattacks against Estonia, kidnapped one of its citizens and increased its troop strength along the Estonia border. But Estonia might not feel such a level of anxiety were it not for the election of President Donald Trump, and his statements about NATO, which Estonia joined in 2004.

Article 5 of the NATO treaty states, "The Parties agree that an armed attack against one or more of them in Europe or North America shall be considered an attack against them all." During the presidential campaign, Trump repeatedly called the utility of NATO into question and specifically questioned the willingness of the U.S. to defend the Baltics. Trump has said that NATO was obsolete. Since his election, Trump has said he "strongly supports" NATO, but his relationship with Russia remains suspicious. The international order is more fragile that it seems. If Trump were to come out and say, "The U.S. will not defend the Baltic States," then the following scenarios could happen.

Volunteers participate in a military training during Estonia's biggest annual military competition.
Source: Raigo Pajula/Getty Images

NATO would collapse

NATO is a collective security agreement. The entire premise is that "an attack on one is an attack on all." Trump thinks the U.S. military is the enforcer of a mafia protection-racket in which the U.S. only provides protection to states that pay up. The alliance itself is rooted in the credibility of its members' commitment. If the U.S. won't come to the defense of Estonia, why would Poland expect the U.S. to come to its defense? The other member states could form a new counter-Russia alliance, but that assumes they'd all be in agreement about standing against Russia.

Deputy Counting Officer Marie Louise Lappin announces the latest count result at the EU referendum count on June 24, 2016, in Belfast, Northern Ireland.
Source: Charles McQuillan/Getty Images

Europe would fragment

The collapse of NATO, or even an American withdrawal from NATO, would result in a split between the NATO countries. There would be those that would bandwagon with Russia, and there would be others that would continue to attempt to balance against Russia. This split would not be on geographic lines and would continue the trend started by Brexit. There is a reason why Russia is supporting Marine Le Pen, and it isn't because they have France's best interest at heart. 

A U.S. soldier stands guard near a U.S. F-22 stealth fighter at the Osan Air Base on Feb. 17, 2016, in Pyeongtaek, South Korea.
Source: Pool/Getty Images

South Korea and Japan would develop nuclear weapons

If the U.S. would not keep its commitment to NATO, why should Japan and South Korea believe that the U.S. would honor its defense treaties with its East Asian allies? The only way for these states to ensure their own survival against a North Korean attack would be to develop their own nuclear deterrent as quickly as possible. The Non-Proliferation Treaty would be dead, and the number of new nuclear states would likely increase beyond these two.

Russian President Vladimir Putin and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu shake hands during a meeting at the Kremlin.
Source: Mikhail Klimentyev/AP

Israel and other Middle Eastern states would turn toward Russia

The U.S. does not have a formal treaty commitment to the defense of Israel or Saudi Arabia, but it does have decades-old friendships with both states. If the U.S. was not seen as a credible friend, these states would look to other powers for help in their lukewarm war with Iran. Israel has increased its ties with Russia in the last year due to the Obama administration's lack of credibility in the region.

The Philippines' and Japan's coast guards participate in a joint anti-piracy exercise in the waters off Manila Bay.
Source: Ted Aljibe/Getty Images

The Philippines and Australia would turn toward China

These states also have mutual defense treaties with the U.S. They would also no longer be able to rely on an American defense commitment. This would be a bigger issue for the Philippines than for Australia and New Zealand, as it is currently in a dispute with China in the South China Sea, and it has already flirted with realigning towards China. Australia would move toward China as a result of the dissolution of TPP, rise of RCEP and Trump's odd antagonism toward Australia. 

A post-liberal order would emerge

The United States-led alliance system has prevented major war in Europe for more than 70 years, on the Korean peninsula for more than 60 years and keeps global trade routes open and free. The global reorientation away from the U.S. and toward Russia and China would be a victory for illiberalism worldwide. It would result in a diminished U.S. and multipolarity by choice. 

There are many ways Trump could disrupt, destroy or demolish the international order — saying he won't defend the Baltic States is just one of them. 

How much do you trust the information in this article?

Jonathan Cristol

Dr. Jonathan Cristol is a fellow at the World Policy Institute (www.worldpolicy.org). He is also a senior fellow at the Center for Civic Engagement at Bard College (www.bard.edu), where for many years he was a professor of international affairs and director of Bard's Globalization and International Affairs Program. Dr. Cristol is an independent advisor/expert at Duco, a global affairs, policy, technology, and security consulting firm (www.ducoexperts.com).

MORE FROM

Randy “Iron Stache” Bryce gets in on the New York City fundraiser game — of a different sort

Randy Bryce met with small dollar progressive donors at a New York dive bar to support his race against Paul Ryan.

Obamacare repeal and replace amendment fails in the Senate

Just six hours after advancing the health care bill to debate, Republicans saw a major setback.

John McCain implored colleagues to “return to regular order.” Senators aren’t sure they can do that.

"It's not an institution people can be proud of."

Senate Republicans advance Obamacare repeal effort to debate

Senate Republicans may have cleared their first hurdle, but many more remain.

Hundreds of disability rights activists vow an indefinite sit-in if the ACA is repealed

This isn't the first time ADAPT has protested the GOP's mission to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act.

Motions to proceed and vote-a-ramas: Here’s how the health care process will play out

There are a lot of moving parts, and even if everything goes right for the GOP, a final vote won't happen until Wednesday.

Randy “Iron Stache” Bryce gets in on the New York City fundraiser game — of a different sort

Randy Bryce met with small dollar progressive donors at a New York dive bar to support his race against Paul Ryan.

Obamacare repeal and replace amendment fails in the Senate

Just six hours after advancing the health care bill to debate, Republicans saw a major setback.

John McCain implored colleagues to “return to regular order.” Senators aren’t sure they can do that.

"It's not an institution people can be proud of."

Senate Republicans advance Obamacare repeal effort to debate

Senate Republicans may have cleared their first hurdle, but many more remain.

Hundreds of disability rights activists vow an indefinite sit-in if the ACA is repealed

This isn't the first time ADAPT has protested the GOP's mission to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act.

Motions to proceed and vote-a-ramas: Here’s how the health care process will play out

There are a lot of moving parts, and even if everything goes right for the GOP, a final vote won't happen until Wednesday.