'USA Today' writer claims NFL star beat his son because he "descended from slaves"

Source: AP
Source: AP
opinion
Mic invites contributors and staff to offer commentary and context about news and timely issues.

Pete Dougherty, a columnist for USA Today in Wisconsin, wrote that Minnesota Vikings running back Adrian Peterson beat his 4-year-old son with a switch in 2014 because he's "descended from slaves," according to screenshots of the article captured by Deadspin.

"Let's ... not forget that Peterson likely is descended from slaves who suffered savage disciplinary beatings generation after generation after generation," Dougherty wrote Thursday. "It excuses nothing but also can't be ignored. This is learned behavior."

The paragraph in question has since been deleted from the column, with an editor's note inserted at the top that reads as follows:

A paragraph in an earlier version of Pete Dougherty's column that included a reference to Peterson's punishment of his 4-year-old son being connected to America's history of slavery was removed. It was poorly reasoned and insensitive. We apologize to all readers who were offended.

Peterson was indicted for child abuse in September 2014 after beating his 4-year-old son and leaving bruises and lacerations on the child's back, buttocks, arms and legs. In November of that year, Peterson pleaded no contest to a reduced charge of misdemeanor reckless assault. He avoided jail time, and was ordered to pay a $4,000 fine and do 80 hours of community service.

Adrian Peterson, Dec. 2016.
Source: 
Hannah Foslien/Getty Images

There are no winners in this scenario. Peterson is a child abuser, his son is an abused child and Dougherty is a paid columnist who drew a lazy and ill-argued conclusion about both using racial essentialist reasoning. 

But logic is also a victim here. Dougherty declines to account for the millions of black American parents — nearly all of whom are descended from slaves, too — who do not abuse their children. He ignores that child abuse statistics are poorly understood from an empirical standpoint, but that available literature suggests that rates between blacks (25%) and whites (20%) differ by just 5%.

Perhaps most damning is that Dougherty uses slavery as a throwaway explanation for alleged black pathology without questioning whether the connection is true. He's not the first white pundit to do this. In 2014, New York magazine's Jonathan Chait debated Ta-Nehisi Coates over the origins of a so-called "culture of poverty" in black communities, arguing that slavery had left a "cultural residue" on blacks that constitutes its own independent roadblock to success.

But few would apply this same reasoning to white people. By Dougherty's logic — considering that whites have similar rates of child abuse as blacks today — is it not equally plausible that white people beat their children at such high rates because of slavery? They were, after all, the ones doing the beating — "generation after generation after generation," as Dougherty put it. 

Why do pundits seem so comfortable arguing that slavery left a cultural stain on black people, but rarely argue that whites — the actual perpetrators and beneficiaries of slavery — were equally tainted, if not more so?

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Zak Cheney Rice

Zak is a Senior Staff Writer at Mic.

MORE FROM

Ten Commandments monument at Arkansas Capitol destroyed

The suspect appears to have broadcast the crash on Facebook Live.

'Hot Mic' podcast: Health care vote, Charges in Laquan McDonald shooting, U.S. image

The important stories to get you caught up for Wednesday.

Venezuela's Supreme Court targeted in helicopter attack amid ongoing crisis

The apparent helicopter attack is the latest escalation of an ongoing political crisis.

Iran calls Supreme Court's travel ban decision "racist" and "unfair"

Iranian officials criticized Trump's de-facto Muslim ban this week.

Kshama Sawant on why Seattle needs an independent investigation into the Charleena Lyles shooting

Seattle City Councilperson Kshama Sawant, member of Socialist Alternative party, discusses the Charleena Lyles investigation, tenant voter registration, why Hillary Clinton lost in 2016 and more.

The EPA seeks to undo clean water rule, putting 117 million Americans' water at risk

The new rule could have "long-reaching consequences for everyone living in the United States.”

Ten Commandments monument at Arkansas Capitol destroyed

The suspect appears to have broadcast the crash on Facebook Live.

'Hot Mic' podcast: Health care vote, Charges in Laquan McDonald shooting, U.S. image

The important stories to get you caught up for Wednesday.

Venezuela's Supreme Court targeted in helicopter attack amid ongoing crisis

The apparent helicopter attack is the latest escalation of an ongoing political crisis.

Iran calls Supreme Court's travel ban decision "racist" and "unfair"

Iranian officials criticized Trump's de-facto Muslim ban this week.

Kshama Sawant on why Seattle needs an independent investigation into the Charleena Lyles shooting

Seattle City Councilperson Kshama Sawant, member of Socialist Alternative party, discusses the Charleena Lyles investigation, tenant voter registration, why Hillary Clinton lost in 2016 and more.

The EPA seeks to undo clean water rule, putting 117 million Americans' water at risk

The new rule could have "long-reaching consequences for everyone living in the United States.”