Immigration Reform 2013: New Policies Would Benefit Everyone

Prosperous nations such as the U.S., Canada, Australia., and the U.K. have always attracted immigrants who are looking for better opportunities. Since the foundation of the United States of America, immigration has been an essential factor to the growth of the nation as well as a continuous source of conflict. In 2007, illegal immigrants outnumbered legal ones at approximately 12 million.

The debate over the economic implications of immigration isn’t clear-cut. On one hand, some argue that the “cost of giving illegal immigrants path to citizenship could outweigh fiscal benefits” because these immigrants lack education, which results in low-paying jobs and small income-tax contribution. This would cost taxpayers $29 billion annually. On the other hand, there are studies that show that the full deportation reduces the GDP by 0.61%, legalization with border control increases it by 0.17% and legalization without border control increases it by 0.53%.

President Barack Obama has said on the matter, “We are not going to ship back 12 million people, we are not going to do it as a practical matter...So what I’ve proposed…is you say we’re going to bring these folks out of the shadows. We’re going to make them pay a fine, they are going to have to learn English, they are going to have to go to the back of the line…but they will have a pathway to citizenship over the course of 10 years.”

Clearly, Obama is emphasizing on the importance of immigrants’ integration in the society. Successful integration of immigrants is a key component of their success because it strengthens communities and promotes growth over the long run. For example, Richard Florida and Charlotta Mellander found that nations that focus more on immigrants’ integration achieve higher levels of economic competitiveness, are more innovative, and have higher rates of entrepreneurship.

One way to measure the impact of integration policies is to use comparative evidence as a benchmark.

The Immigration Policy Center (IPC) is the U.S. partner for a major international comparative study on integration laws across Europe, Canada, and the U.S. The Migrant Integration Policy Index, MIPEX, is a reference tool that measures and compares the immigration and integration policies of 31 countries.

The 148 questions in the MIPEX survey cover seven policy areas of integration: labor market mobility, family reunion, access to education, political participation, long-term residence, access to citizenship, and anti-discrimination laws and protections. Each of the seven policy areas is divided into sub-categories and scored on a scale of 0 to 100.

Sweden, Portugal, Canada, Finland and the Netherlands score highest on overall integration, while the lowest rankings go to Lithuania, Malta, Slovakia, Cyprus and Latvia.

The MIPEX ranked the U.S. ninth overall and first in terms of its strong anti-discrimination laws and protections. In addition to this, the U.S. also ranked high on the access to citizenship because it encourages newcomers to become citizens in order to fully participate in American public life. Compared with other countries, legal immigrants in the U.S. enjoy employment opportunities, but many workers are obligated to look for jobs below their skill level because the U.S. doesn’t facilitate the recognition of foreign diplomas. On the opportunity to reunite with close family members, the U.S. received high marks for giving “a slightly favourable chance of immigration for the immediate family members of immigrants.”

However, MIPEX also acknowledges that the lowest score goes to long-term residence because the U.S.’s complex immigration laws, limited visa availability, high fees, and long backlogs may make it challenging for immigrants to integrate fully in the American life. In addition, the second lowest score goes to political participation because unlike most European countries, non-citizens in the U.S cannot vote in federal elections and are not represented by federally sponsored advisory bodies.

Finally, MIPEX mentions that states including Illinois, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Maryland and Washington are taking the lead on immigrant integration.

The MIPEX report is not without some drawbacks. One limitation is related to the fact that the survey questions reflect European systems of government and policies that don’t necessarily apply to U.S. laws. Michele Waslin, a senior policy analyst at the IPC said, “Integration is happening in the U.S despite the fact that we don’t have a national strategy and don’t have some of the same laws and policies that other countries have”.

One way to address the immigration issue is to develop appropriate, country-specific integration policies. The MIPEX index offers policymakers a framework for analyzing and comparing immigrants’ integration, in addition to assessing the best and the worst practices. 

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Olga Jbeili

I hold an MSc in Development Economics and a Graduate Diploma in Economics from the University of Sussex. Most recently I was working as a research officer at Sussex uni. I previously worked at the Carnegie Endowment in Beirut where I assisted scholars in researches related to food security and land acquisitions, peak-oil and rentier economies, sovereign wealth funds, labour markets among other topics... I am also particularly interested in the political economic situation in the developing and emerging economies and how this relationship might affect growth and long-run development.

MORE FROM

Watchdog groups sue Trump for deleting tweets, allegedly violating Presidential Records Act

Trump's deleted tweets may come back to haunt him.

Grizzly bear protections in Yellowstone National park are ending

A final ruling by US government officials will strike the Yellowstone grizzly bear from the list of threatened species after its population increased to 700.

Another day, another off-camera White House press briefing

The move to scale back on-camera press briefings comes amid Trump's increasing unwillingness to interact with the press.

Minneapolis might get a $15 minimum wage, but restaurant workers aren't celebrating

Discord has been brewing in Minneapolis over whether tipped work will be counted toward a $15 minimum wage.

These abysmal new poll numbers for House health care bill don't bode well for Senate version

Only 34% of Republicans approve of the new proposed law.

'Pizzagate' shooter gets 4-year prison sentence, lawyers urged judge to deter vigilantism

Welch stormed a Washington, D.C., pizza place and shot off a firearm because of the internet.

Watchdog groups sue Trump for deleting tweets, allegedly violating Presidential Records Act

Trump's deleted tweets may come back to haunt him.

Grizzly bear protections in Yellowstone National park are ending

A final ruling by US government officials will strike the Yellowstone grizzly bear from the list of threatened species after its population increased to 700.

Another day, another off-camera White House press briefing

The move to scale back on-camera press briefings comes amid Trump's increasing unwillingness to interact with the press.

Minneapolis might get a $15 minimum wage, but restaurant workers aren't celebrating

Discord has been brewing in Minneapolis over whether tipped work will be counted toward a $15 minimum wage.

These abysmal new poll numbers for House health care bill don't bode well for Senate version

Only 34% of Republicans approve of the new proposed law.

'Pizzagate' shooter gets 4-year prison sentence, lawyers urged judge to deter vigilantism

Welch stormed a Washington, D.C., pizza place and shot off a firearm because of the internet.