Cell Phones On Planes: FAA Probably Won't Allow Anytime Soon

In December, then-Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Chairman Julius Genachowski wrote a letter to his counterpart at the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Acting Administrator Michael Huerta, asking to allow greater use of electronics in-flight.

Though the FAA is reportedly considering the potential of expanded wireless access and its associated health and safety concerns, and while some European airliners already allow voice calls in-flight, it’s unlikely the FAA will extend this capability to Americans. And that may be more a function of what we want than what the FAA is willing to do.

According to a survey of 1,788 consumers completed early last month by the Travel Leaders Group, nearly 80% of respondents are opposed to allowing in-flight calls. This is the composite of several responses. While 49.7% are opposed to full phone use in-flight, 31.3% are in favor of full phone use so long as voice calls are prohibited.

It would not be a leap to claim that the reason underlying little support for in-flight calls is a product of intense displeasure at the prospect of having to overhear one-sided conversations, what some researchers have dubbed “halfalogues.” Authors Joe Palca and Flora Lichtman write in their book, Annoying: The Science of What Bugs Us, that much of this annoyance comes from the cognitive frustration in processing these half-conversations.

Our brains have an innate desire to form patterns from our environment, so when given half a conversation we cannot help but attempt to fill-in the gap. Of course, we’re often less than successful in clairvoyantly divining the emerging transcript of a phone conversation. The dual-burden of having to craft the other half of the dialogue while being proven wrong in real-time is maddening. Not that you need anyone to tell you that.

Not only is it the case that processing these calls into our mental framework is uncomfortable, but it is also less escapable than full conversations. A research team at the University of San Diego found that halfalogues are significantly more distracting to bystanders than two-sided conversations. To extend the cognitive-processing hypothesis, this may be because it’s easier to process and place on the mental backburner a full conversation.

While in-flight voice calls are unlikely to catch on, there’s little we can do to escape the plight of having to listen to them on the ground.

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Rajiv Narayan

I'm currently a contributing curator at Upworthy and a grad student at the University of Oxford, where I study Medical Anthropology. In the last year I was an Associate at the healthcare information firm Close Concerns, where I covered research, drug, and policy developments in obesity and public health. Before that I was a Research Assistant at Social Policy Research Associates. And not too long before that I was finishing my undergraduate studies at the University of California, Davis, where I was very privileged to be a Regents Scholar and graduate Phi Beta Kappa with highest honors in a self-designed major. In college I was a 2010 Young People For fellow and the Senior Fellow for Health Policy at the Roosevelt Institute Campus Network. At various points over the last 4 years I've worked on an urban farm in Milwaukee, interned at the California State Assembly, and taught classes on the Social Theory of Eating Disorders at UC Davis. On the academic side, I researched obesity legislation in Argentina, food stamps in California, the racial dynamics of obesity policy in Southern States, and fat acceptance activism in California.

MORE FROM

These are the 9 best 'America’s Got Talent' Golden Buzzer moments of all time

A look at the acts that have earned the show's distinct honor.

Why was 'BoJack Horseman' pulled from China's iQiyi streaming service?

The series has run afoul of the country's notoriously difficult censors.

These 'Pretty Little Liars' characters could all be AD

The answer will finally be revealed on Tuesday night.

'The Carmichael Show' mass shooting episode to air this week after pushback from cast

The episode was initially meant to be aired the day of the shooting at the Congressional Baseball Game practice.

These celebrities have already taken Lin-Manuel Miranda's #Ham4All challenge

Famous faces ranging from Gina Rodriguez to Rainn Wilson dust off their singing chops for a good cause.

This 'Iron Man 2' Easter egg involving Spider-Man will blow your mind

Peter Parker has a very brief but important cameo in 'Iron Man 2.'

These are the 9 best 'America’s Got Talent' Golden Buzzer moments of all time

A look at the acts that have earned the show's distinct honor.

Why was 'BoJack Horseman' pulled from China's iQiyi streaming service?

The series has run afoul of the country's notoriously difficult censors.

These 'Pretty Little Liars' characters could all be AD

The answer will finally be revealed on Tuesday night.

'The Carmichael Show' mass shooting episode to air this week after pushback from cast

The episode was initially meant to be aired the day of the shooting at the Congressional Baseball Game practice.

These celebrities have already taken Lin-Manuel Miranda's #Ham4All challenge

Famous faces ranging from Gina Rodriguez to Rainn Wilson dust off their singing chops for a good cause.

This 'Iron Man 2' Easter egg involving Spider-Man will blow your mind

Peter Parker has a very brief but important cameo in 'Iron Man 2.'