Trent Franks Abortion: The GOP Keeps Finding Ways to Shoot Itself in the Foot On Women's Rights

Wednesday, the day after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit struck down an Arizona law that would ban abortions after 20 weeks of pregnancy, Rep. Trent Franks (R-Ariz.) announced plans to reintroduce a bill to challenge Roe v. Wade and establish a nationwide restriction on women’s abortion rights. Franks has enlisted a group of fellow representatives to speak in support of the bill. Of these supporters only one, Michelle Bachmann (R-Minn.), is a woman.

The problem with Franks’ initiative is twofold. First, the bill itself is flawed. Franks cites the recent case of illegal abortion provider Kermit Gosnell in Philadelphia as justification for the bill. However, these restrictive laws, although they may dissuade some women from abortion, will only push more women to subject themselves to dangerous off-the-books procedures. This policy would also endanger women’s rights to abortions as established by the Roe v. Wade Supreme Court decision, which established a women’s constitutional right to an abortion in the first three months of pregnancy.

A recent poll shows that for the first time, a majority of adults say that abortion should be legal always or most of the time. Bill McIntruff, who conducted the NBC News/Wall Street Journal poll, suggests that rhetoric from lawmakers such as Franks and controversial remarks on abortion and rape by two Republican senate candidates in 2012 may have had an effect.

Roe v. Wade was also cited in Idaho and Georgia where similar legislation was blocked. These “fetal pain” laws are based on the notion that a fetus can feel pain after 20 weeks. An NBC News report disputes this finding, citing a University of California study that presented data indicating that fetuses are incapable of feeling pain until around the 28th week.   

A second set of problems with Rep. Franks’ proposal is that the manner in which he is approaching the issue is flawed and adds to the narrative of an increasingly disconnected GOP. By inviting only one woman and eight men to speak in support of his bill, the panel is drawing comparisons to a similar panel last February in which House Oversight Committee Chairman Rep. Darrell Issa (R-Calif.) held an all-male discussion on the issue of women’s access to birth control and did not invite any women to testify before a hearing on birth-control regulation.

With only 18.3% of Congress made up of women, neither party can be said to sufficiently represent women and minorities. However, for the first time the majority of Democratic members of this Congress are not white men. However, the Republican members of Congress are 89% white men.

If Franks and his Republican colleagues would like to advance women’s-rights legislation, it would be wise of them to advance conservative causes with female support rather than legislation such as the “fetal pain” laws that stand no chance of passing in Congress and make the party increasingly unpopular. 

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Maxime Fischer-Zernin

Studying Political Science at Duke University (T. '15). His interests lie primarily in American national security and foreign policy. He is currently an Editor-at-Large for the Duke Political Review, and is a contributor for PolicyMic.com.

MORE FROM

Bill Cosby to appear in court for alleged 1974 assault of 15-year-old girl

Cosby will appear in court on July 30, 2018 for allegedly forcing a teen girl to perform oral sex on him over 40 years ago.

Nearly 850 backlogged rape kits were found infested with mold in Texas

The mold-infested rape kits don't appear to have contaminated the DNA samples inside, according to authorities.

Season 11 of 'The X-Files' will be written entirely by men

Only six women have ever written for the beloved sci-fi show, which boasts over 200 episodes and spawned two feature-length films.

Does nursing require a "woman’s touch"? These male nurses say no.

Christian Martin and Dan Douglas are two men working as nurses — and it's mostly NBD.

The GOP health care bill's one-year ban on Planned Parenthood is a bigger problem than you think

Compared to the millions who will lose coverage, restricting federal funds for just 365 days doesn't seem that bad. But it is.

There's a new effort to recall Judge Aaron Perksy, who sentenced Brock Turner

If voters in Persky's county collect enough signatures, the judge could be on the chopping block in 2018.

Bill Cosby to appear in court for alleged 1974 assault of 15-year-old girl

Cosby will appear in court on July 30, 2018 for allegedly forcing a teen girl to perform oral sex on him over 40 years ago.

Nearly 850 backlogged rape kits were found infested with mold in Texas

The mold-infested rape kits don't appear to have contaminated the DNA samples inside, according to authorities.

Season 11 of 'The X-Files' will be written entirely by men

Only six women have ever written for the beloved sci-fi show, which boasts over 200 episodes and spawned two feature-length films.

Does nursing require a "woman’s touch"? These male nurses say no.

Christian Martin and Dan Douglas are two men working as nurses — and it's mostly NBD.

The GOP health care bill's one-year ban on Planned Parenthood is a bigger problem than you think

Compared to the millions who will lose coverage, restricting federal funds for just 365 days doesn't seem that bad. But it is.

There's a new effort to recall Judge Aaron Perksy, who sentenced Brock Turner

If voters in Persky's county collect enough signatures, the judge could be on the chopping block in 2018.