Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Ruling: What is Synthetic DNA?

In a unanimous decision released Thursday, the Supreme Court ruled that while synthetic DNA is patentable, naturally isolated DNA is not. The ruling, based on Myriad Genetic's claim to the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes — both of which are key indicators of breast and ovarian cancer risk — was decided in large part because of the distinction that synthetic DNA is not naturally occurring. But what exactly is synthetic DNA?

Synthetic genes are genes produced in a laboratory by artificial gene synthesis. These genes are not based on any naturally pre-existing DNA sequences, and the possibilities for unique synthetic genes is almost endless. These genes are particularly useful for vaccine development, gene therapy, and molecular engineering.

On the other hand, the now non-patentable DNA consists of genes that are isolated from the natural world, "captured," and then copied. Myriad argued that it was not patenting anyone's genes, but rather the lab-made copies. However, because the copies are identical, patenting their gene sequence would in effect patent the genes present in all of us.

Prior to the case, the U.S. Patent Office accepted patents on isolated DNA sequences as a composition of matter, but today's decision stated that because isolated DNA is captured, it is not invented but rather naturally occurring, and thus is not patentable; the same way no one can patent sugar, coal, or water. According to the ACLU, 20%t of all identified human genes have been patented.

During oral arguments, Gregory Castanias, Myriad's lawyer, suggested an analogy to baseball: "A baseball bat doesn’t exist until it's isolated from a tree," he said. "But that’s still the product of human invention to decide where to begin the bat and where to end the bat."


How much do you trust the information in this article?

Maxime Fischer-Zernin

Studying Political Science at Duke University (T. '15). His interests lie primarily in American national security and foreign policy. He is currently an Editor-at-Large for the Duke Political Review, and is a contributor for PolicyMic.com.

MORE FROM

Amid new revelations, here’s what we’ve learned about the Russian lawyer who met with Trump Jr.

The picture of Natalia Veselnitskaya is coming into clearer focus.

Republican Senator urges whoever leaked Russia/Sessions phone calls to release whole conversation

Sen. Chuck Grassley wants the person who leaked intelligence about Attorney General Jeff Sessions and Russian ambassador Sergey Kislyak to come forward with more information.

Donald Trump Jr. and Paul Manafort now to testify before Senate committee behind closed doors

Trump Jr. and Manafort have avoided a subpoena and will testify behind closed doors — for now.

Hope Hicks reportedly tried to rein Trump in during explosive ‘Times’ interview. It didn’t work.

The low-profile Trump Whisperer is one of the few in the president's orbit to enjoy job security.

Scaramucci once asked Obama if he’d be softer on Wall Street. It didn’t end well.

The exchange came during a CNBC town hall on the financial crisis, two years into Obama’s presidency.

Trump blasts Hilary Clinton, Comey and ‘Amazon Washington Post’ in tweet storm

He also defended Don Jr. and called Democrats "obstructionists" with "no ideas."

Amid new revelations, here’s what we’ve learned about the Russian lawyer who met with Trump Jr.

The picture of Natalia Veselnitskaya is coming into clearer focus.

Republican Senator urges whoever leaked Russia/Sessions phone calls to release whole conversation

Sen. Chuck Grassley wants the person who leaked intelligence about Attorney General Jeff Sessions and Russian ambassador Sergey Kislyak to come forward with more information.

Donald Trump Jr. and Paul Manafort now to testify before Senate committee behind closed doors

Trump Jr. and Manafort have avoided a subpoena and will testify behind closed doors — for now.

Hope Hicks reportedly tried to rein Trump in during explosive ‘Times’ interview. It didn’t work.

The low-profile Trump Whisperer is one of the few in the president's orbit to enjoy job security.

Scaramucci once asked Obama if he’d be softer on Wall Street. It didn’t end well.

The exchange came during a CNBC town hall on the financial crisis, two years into Obama’s presidency.

Trump blasts Hilary Clinton, Comey and ‘Amazon Washington Post’ in tweet storm

He also defended Don Jr. and called Democrats "obstructionists" with "no ideas."