Israeli Preemption is Not an Option

Last month, my PolicyMic colleague Gabriel Kohan argued that a nuclear-armed Iran poses a grave threat to peace and stability in the Middle East. This relies on the assumption that Iran is a dire threat to Middle Eastern peace. I disagree with this argument for a number of reasons.

First, the threat posed by Iran to Middle Eastern peace is exaggerated not just in Kohan’s piece but also in the mainstream media. The 2007 National Intelligence Estimate stated that Iran ended its nuclear weapons program in 2003 and has not restarted it as of mid-2007. While some say that Iran may have resumed “research” on how to build a nuclear bomb, it is not engaged in any actual development. In other words, Iran does not have a nuclear weapon and is not trying to build one at the moment. On the other hand, Israel has hundreds of nuclear weapons and refuses to allow any inspections or sign the Non-Proliferation Treaty.

It is true that Iran has exercised its regional ambitions through its support of Hezbollah in Lebanon, Hamas in Gaza and arming of sectarian groups in Iraq. However, Iran never invaded Lebanon, Gaza or Iraq. Israel has invaded Lebanon numerous times throughout the past thirty years, most notably in 1982 and 2006. These invasions have resulted in numerous civilian casualties and bloody massacres, most of the deaths being Arab. Hezbollah (which means “party of God” in Arabic) is an Islamist political party that formed after Israel’s 1982 invasion of Lebanon to provide resistance against Israeli aggression. While Hezbollah has an armed militia wing that has engaged in terrorism against Israel, it is important to note that Hezbollah's actions are a reaction to Israel’s aggressive behavior.

The same applies to Gaza. Like Hezbollah, Hamas, also an Islamist organization, has engaged in terrorist activities against Israeli civilians. But this is in response to Israel’s crippling blockade of the Gaza Strip, which continues to be a nightmare for Palestinians despite Israel’s “easing”. Before Israel’s invasion of Gaza, Hamas did honor a ceasefire. However, in November 4, 2008, Israel killed six Hamas fighters, which provoked Hamas to commit acts of violence against Israel. During the 2008-2009 Israeli invasion of Gaza, over 1,400 Palestinians and a dozen Israelis were killed. As in Lebanon, most of the deaths were Arab.

As for Iraq, while Iran’s meddling has perpetuated sectarian violence, it did not invade that country, destroy its infrastructure and create the conditions for sectarianism -- the United States did that. While Iran is certainly not the biggest promoter of peace and human rights, the United States and Israel, through their actions, proved to be far bigger threats to peace in the Middle East than Iran. Therefore, claims about Iran’s threat to peace and stability in the region are exaggerated.

Secondly, Israel does not have the right, under international law, to pre-emptively strike Iran. Under international law, a state can use force in self-defense against an armed attack or when authorized by the United Nations Security Council to do so. Any use of force that does not meet any of these conditions is an illegal use of force or “war of aggression”. A pre-emptive strike does not satisfy these legal requirements and, thus, is illegal under international law.

If Israel wants peace, there are other ways to achieve this, such as eliminating its nuclear weapons, signing the Non-Proliferation Treaty and reaching a just peace agreement with the Palestinians. A pre-emptive strike against Iran is unnecessary, illegal and would do more harm than good.

Photo CreditWikimedia Commons 

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Adam Hudson

Adam Hudson is a journalist, writer, photographer, and San Francisco Bay Area native. Adam graduated from Stanford University in 2010 with a BA in International Relations, minoring in Middle Eastern Languages, Literatures and Cultures, with a focus on the Arabic language. In the winter of 2010, he traveled overseas to the University of Oxford where he studied international humanitarian law and public policy. Adam has been passionate about politics and a stalwart advocate of progressive causes since he was a teenager. At Stanford, he was involved in the NAACP, co-chairing the Education Committee for two years, and co-founded the student antiwar group Stanford Says No to War. In Fall 2012, he was an editorial intern at The Nation magazine in New York City. As a journalist, Adam focuses on war and peace issues, human rights, and police brutality. His work has appeared on PolicyMic.com, Examiner.com, Turnstyle News, and The Nation. He has also given political commentary on radio stations, such as 94.1 FM KPFA in Berkeley, California, 99.5 FM WBAI in New York City, and 900 AM WURD in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Adam continues his activism by supporting movements like Occupy Wall Street. Fun facts about Adam: he is an avid runner, plays drums, and a huge anime fan. You can his more of his work on his website: http://adamhudson.org/

MORE FROM

When cops kill, paying their victims' families can be a cold, calculating process, attorneys say

Black lives are often seen as having less monetary value in the eyes of the law.

Ava Le'Ray Barrin, 17-year-old transgender girl, killed in Georgia

Barrin, 17, wanted to be a model.

Ten Commandments monument at Arkansas Capitol destroyed

The suspect appears to have broadcast the crash on Facebook Live.

'Hot Mic' podcast: Health care vote, Charges in Laquan McDonald shooting, U.S. image

The important stories to get you caught up for Wednesday.

Venezuela's Supreme Court targeted in helicopter attack amid ongoing crisis

The apparent helicopter attack is the latest escalation of an ongoing political crisis.

Iran calls Supreme Court's travel ban decision "racist" and "unfair"

Iranian officials criticized Trump's de-facto Muslim ban this week.

When cops kill, paying their victims' families can be a cold, calculating process, attorneys say

Black lives are often seen as having less monetary value in the eyes of the law.

Ava Le'Ray Barrin, 17-year-old transgender girl, killed in Georgia

Barrin, 17, wanted to be a model.

Ten Commandments monument at Arkansas Capitol destroyed

The suspect appears to have broadcast the crash on Facebook Live.

'Hot Mic' podcast: Health care vote, Charges in Laquan McDonald shooting, U.S. image

The important stories to get you caught up for Wednesday.

Venezuela's Supreme Court targeted in helicopter attack amid ongoing crisis

The apparent helicopter attack is the latest escalation of an ongoing political crisis.

Iran calls Supreme Court's travel ban decision "racist" and "unfair"

Iranian officials criticized Trump's de-facto Muslim ban this week.