Replace Will Be Tougher Than Repeal For Health Reform

The recent ruling by federal judge Roger Vinson against the Affordable Care Act (ACA) shocked no one, though he did manage to deliver a surprise.

Judge Vinson, a conservative judge appointed by President Reagan, fulfilled expectations by denying the constitutionality of the ACA’s individual health insurance mandate. The plaintiffs challenged the government’s ability to require everyone to buy health coverage and Vinson agreed in an opinion published last week.

The surprising part of his decision was the scope. Not only did he strike the insurance mandate, he rejected the entire bill.

This decision will have little tangible effect on the law since states are already developing infrastructure to support the ACA’s directives and the case likely won’t be settled until the Supreme Court enters a decision. Nevertheless, many see Judge Vinson’s ruling as a turning point in the health reform debate.

By chucking the whole bill Vinson validates the “repeal and replace” -ers. These critics of the bill want Congress to drop the ACA and replace it with other laws. They argue replacement legislation targeting specific changes to the health system would achieve reform without including an individual insurance mandate. If the Supreme Court follows Vinson’s precedent, they will achieve the “repeal” part of this plan. Unfortunately, the “replace” part will be harder.

Replacing the ACA means trying to rebuild health reform in a noxious political environment. Aspiring reformers would need to navigate a voting public that has lost patience after over two years of debate. They would also need to overcome other politicians’ reticence to address a divisive issue. Those present for the vitriol at previous regional town hall meetings will understand why few politicians look forward to renewed health reform discussions.

Because of this public and political distaste for health reform, replacement legislation is a non-starter.

With replacement legislation untenable in the current political environment, repealing the ACA per Judge Vinson’s decision would effectively table health reform. This would be a blow to the President and a sad end to the most recent chapter in the debate. While imperfect, the legislation is a step toward a better health system. Repeal would erase this progress and leave America with little hope for change.

Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Sam Wertheimer

Sam works as a research assistant in the health group at a a non-partisan think tank. He graduated from Stanford in 2007 and received an MPH from The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice in 2009. Opinions expressed here are his own.

MORE FROM

Hillary Clinton says Republicans will be the "death party" if they pass health care bill

Hillary Clinton spoke out against the Republican's proposed bill on Twitter.

It's time to redefine the clitoris, according to sex education experts

"Words matter. They shape and mold our ideas and beliefs about our purpose, our bodies, our self-worth and our place in the world around us."

Al-Jazeera becomes a target amid Qatar diplomatic crisis

Gulf states are demanding the broadcaster be shut down.

5 blocks of London apartments to be evacuated over potentially flammable cladding

800 North London apartments will be evacuated following a fire inspection that turned up evidence that the buildings could be unsafe.

Tomi Lahren wants to rally women to her side after criticizing feminists and "pro-choicers"

"My view on abortion is not black-and-white," Lahren said.

These 5 states are drafting laws to limit protests on college campuses

The legislation is intended to protect free speech on campus.

Hillary Clinton says Republicans will be the "death party" if they pass health care bill

Hillary Clinton spoke out against the Republican's proposed bill on Twitter.

It's time to redefine the clitoris, according to sex education experts

"Words matter. They shape and mold our ideas and beliefs about our purpose, our bodies, our self-worth and our place in the world around us."

Al-Jazeera becomes a target amid Qatar diplomatic crisis

Gulf states are demanding the broadcaster be shut down.

5 blocks of London apartments to be evacuated over potentially flammable cladding

800 North London apartments will be evacuated following a fire inspection that turned up evidence that the buildings could be unsafe.

Tomi Lahren wants to rally women to her side after criticizing feminists and "pro-choicers"

"My view on abortion is not black-and-white," Lahren said.

These 5 states are drafting laws to limit protests on college campuses

The legislation is intended to protect free speech on campus.