Did Robin Thicke Steal "Blurred Lines" From Marvin Gaye?

The family of legendary soul singer Marvin Gaye heard Robin Thicke's summer hit "Blurred Lines" and though it sounded a bit too much like Gaye's 1977 single, "Got to Give It Up." Naturally, a lawsuit came along. But this is where it gets weird — it's Thicke who's suing Gaye's family. 

The Hollywood Reporter got its hands on a copy of Thicke's lawsuit which states, "Plaintiffs, who have the utmost respect for and admiration of Marvin Gaye, Funkadelic and their musical legacies, reluctantly file this action in the face of multiple adverse claims from alleged successors in interest to those artists. Defendants continue to insist that plaintiffs' massively successful composition, 'Blurred Lines,' copies 'their' compositions."  

In other words, Gaye's camp is saying the music has been lifted and Thicke is striking back preemptively and saying no way.

I know artists sample and share material. But when is artistic license just plain stealing? And when should credit (monetary or otherwise) be given?

Check this out. Doesn’t sound to me like the lines are all that blurred.


And here’s the original Marvin Gaye song without the comparison.


So in the face of being sued, Robin Thicke decided to sue to “protect his rights,” arguing that the only thing in common between the two songs is “commonplace musical elements.”

I did the ultimate test of pop music and played the Marvin Gaye song for a couple of 14-year-olds, who bet me their Starbucks money that it was Thicke's "Blurred Lines." So the similarity is not in question. How it’s being handled, though, is what I have a lot of questions about.

It’s scary to think that you can put something out there artistically and have it stolen or repurposed and that copyright law may not protect you. Intellectual property is tricky, I know. Many things can bear a resemblance to many other things and yet the paths and the works of the creators may never have crossed.

But in this case it seems the cross-over is simply too dramatic to be anything short of stealing. So, does the Gaye family deserve compensation? Should Thicke and his fellow “musicians” publicly apologize? And how do we promote sharing and community and collaboration while still protecting the creations of individuals and groups alike?

When it comes to art, just how blurred are the lines really? We are all influenced daily by everything we see and hear and experience. So much so that it’s hard to know where one thought or idea came from.

How much do you trust the information in this article?

Jenny Block

Jenny Block is a lifestyle and travel writer and the author of “Open: Love, Sex, and Life in an Open Marriage” (2008 Lambda Literary Award). Jenny holds both her BA and her MA in English from Virginia Commonwealth University and taught college composition for nearly ten years. She is a frequent contributor to a number of high-profile publications and websites, including www.huffingtonpost.com, www.FoxNews.com, www.EdgeOnTheNet.com, and Curve Magazine. Her essays have been featured in the books, “It’s a Girl: Women Writers on Raising Daughters,” “One Big Happy Family,” and “The Divinity of Dogs.” Twitter: Jenny_Block Facebook: Jenny Block Website: www.jennyonthepage.com

MORE FROM

‘Insecure’ season two is television for us, by us — and it’s even better than before

Creator Issa Rae shouldn't sweat the Emmy snub — her connection with her core audience is what really makes this series shine.

We talked to military experts about who will win the Iron Throne

Does Dany have a chance? Historians, tacticians and scholars weigh in on the ultimate outcome of 'Game of Thrones.'

‘Game of Thrones’ Season 7, Episode 2 Trailer: New alliances may form in “Stormborn”

Jon Snow and Daenerys Targaryen may have an unexpected intermediary.

Tyler, the Creator is still a “walking paradox” on the rumor-baiting ‘Flower Boy’

Is he queer? Maybe. Does he know how to use the speculation to further his art? Definitely.

Note to Ryan Murphy: ‘American Horror Story’ reveals don’t need to be a scavenger hunt

The title and premiere date of the seventh season of 'American Horror Story' were revealed Thursday.

‘Wet Hot American Summer: Ten Years Later’ proves sometimes it’s OK to skip the reunion

If you're looking to trim down your Netflix consumption, start by avoiding this pointless sequel series.

‘Insecure’ season two is television for us, by us — and it’s even better than before

Creator Issa Rae shouldn't sweat the Emmy snub — her connection with her core audience is what really makes this series shine.

We talked to military experts about who will win the Iron Throne

Does Dany have a chance? Historians, tacticians and scholars weigh in on the ultimate outcome of 'Game of Thrones.'

‘Game of Thrones’ Season 7, Episode 2 Trailer: New alliances may form in “Stormborn”

Jon Snow and Daenerys Targaryen may have an unexpected intermediary.

Tyler, the Creator is still a “walking paradox” on the rumor-baiting ‘Flower Boy’

Is he queer? Maybe. Does he know how to use the speculation to further his art? Definitely.

Note to Ryan Murphy: ‘American Horror Story’ reveals don’t need to be a scavenger hunt

The title and premiere date of the seventh season of 'American Horror Story' were revealed Thursday.

‘Wet Hot American Summer: Ten Years Later’ proves sometimes it’s OK to skip the reunion

If you're looking to trim down your Netflix consumption, start by avoiding this pointless sequel series.