Burt v. Titlow: Everything You Need to Know About the Murder Case That Went to the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court resumed its duties on Monday, beginning a new session that will be remembered for starting during the current government shutdown. Thankfully, the Court is upholding its constitutional duties and beginning its judicial season on time. Unfortunately, the same can't be said for all branches of government.

One case of note this session is Burt v. Titlow, a murder case that could set an interesting precedent for defendants who receive questionable advice from their lawyers. In August 2000, Vonlee Nicole Titlow assisted his aunt Billie in the murder his uncle Donald Rogers. Titlow took $100,000 in gifts and cash from the estate in exchange for keeping quiet about the murder. After being charged with first-degree murder, Titlow's lawyer negotiated a plea deal that would give him seven to 15 years in prison for manslaughter if he testified against Billie. Titlow accepted the deal, but before sentencing, a sheriff's deputy suggested he withdraw his plea and consult another attorney. He followed the advice, hired a new attorney, and withdrew the former plea. After going to trial with his new attorney, Titlow was convicted of second-degree murder and given a much stricter sentence of 20-40 years in prison.

Titlow accused his second attorney of "ineffective assistance of counsel" for letting him withdraw his first guilty plea. The original trial court and the court of appeals refused the claim. Titlow then petitioned the Michigan Supreme Court to hear his case, in which it was also denied. The district court ruled that Titlow's case failed to meet the standard for overturning under the Anti-Terrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act (AEDPA). The AEDPA, passed in 1996 with overwhelming bipartisan support, makes it difficult for federal judges to grant relief unless the state court's decision resulted in a ruling that involved a perverse application of federal law, or was based on "an unreasonable determination of the facts in light of the evidence presented in the state court proceeding."

For legal wonks, the questions before the Court in this case are threefold. First, did the circuit court give appropriate deference to the Michigan trial court under the AEDPA? Second, can a defendant establish prejudice in an ineffective assistance claim by showing testimony that he would have accepted the plea offer absent the attorney's poor advice? Third, does the Court's decision in Lafler v. Cooper, a previous case, require a state trial court to resentence the defendant when they claim that ineffective assistance of counsel caused them to reject a plea offer?

Opening arguments for the case began Tuesday, and SCOTUSBLOG has the case's particulars here.

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Alexander de Avila

Alexander is a Political columnist at PolicyMic. He is a graduate of Claremont McKenna College's school of Government, focusing his studies on international politics and the impact of emerging technologies on government and war. He has experience working at the House Committee on Foreign Affairs, and as a research assistant at TSKB in Istanbul exploring alternative energy sources.

MORE FROM

8 of the biggest moments from the 48th NYC LGBT Pride March

The biggest Pride event in the world was a sight to behold.

Movement for Black Lives activists disrupt Minneapolis Pride to protest Philando Castile verdict

Protesters reportedly held signs with messages like "No KKKops at Pride."

Protesters reportedly arrested near NYC's Stonewall Inn, Pride March endpoint

The reason for the arrests were not immediately known.

Marchers arrested in Istanbul as Pride parade continues despite cancellation

The organizers' decision to move forward with the previously cancelled march led to clashes with police.

Car slams into Eid celebrants in UK, injuring 6; police say terrorism isn't suspected

Police say they believe an Eid celebrant was behind the wheel of the car that injured six outside a mosque.

Oil truck explodes in Pakistan, killing at least 153

The deadly fire broke out as residents rushed to collect the leaking oil from the overturned tanker.

8 of the biggest moments from the 48th NYC LGBT Pride March

The biggest Pride event in the world was a sight to behold.

Movement for Black Lives activists disrupt Minneapolis Pride to protest Philando Castile verdict

Protesters reportedly held signs with messages like "No KKKops at Pride."

Protesters reportedly arrested near NYC's Stonewall Inn, Pride March endpoint

The reason for the arrests were not immediately known.

Marchers arrested in Istanbul as Pride parade continues despite cancellation

The organizers' decision to move forward with the previously cancelled march led to clashes with police.

Car slams into Eid celebrants in UK, injuring 6; police say terrorism isn't suspected

Police say they believe an Eid celebrant was behind the wheel of the car that injured six outside a mosque.

Oil truck explodes in Pakistan, killing at least 153

The deadly fire broke out as residents rushed to collect the leaking oil from the overturned tanker.