NYC Stop-and-Frisk Policy: Ruling Blocked By Appeals Court

NYC Stop-and-Frisk Policy: Ruling Blocked By Appeals Court

The 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals blocked an order requiring changes to the New York Police Department's stop-and-frisk program on Thursday, and a federal judge has been removed from the case. The court held that Judge Shira Scheindlin's ruling will not move forward until the outcome of the city's appeal has been decided.

In August, Scheindlin heard a challenge to the controversial stop-and-frisk policy. The litigants argued that the Police Department's implementation of the policy had violated the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.


According to the New York Civil Liberties Union, the policy was primarily used to target black and Latino citizens. Scheindlin agreed that the discriminatory implementation of the program was unconstitutional as systemic racial bias conflicts with the Constitution's promise of "equal protection of the laws." To rectify the problem, Scheindlin ordered a number of changes including the addition of a monitor who would help the department fix the program and train officers.

The ruling was a win for civil rights activists who had long argued that the policy violated the Constitution. However, the police Department appealed the decision, which led to the circuit court staying the changes to the stop-and-frisk policy and removing the lower court judge. 

The appeals court said that Scheindlin needed to be removed from the case because she violated the code of conduct for federal judges. She had possibly compromised the case by failing to maintain a public appearance of impartiality. Scheindlin had given a number of media interviews and public statements responding to criticism of the court.

How much do you trust the information in this article?

Caitlin Bancroft

is an abortion rights activist. She has a B.A. in Political Science from Saint Louis University and is pursuing her J.D. at The George Washington University Law School. When she's not yelling at her textbooks, she likes to swim and take part in the capital’s vibrant feminist scene. You can share her never-ceasing pro-choice outrage on libertytochoose.tumblr.com.

MORE FROM

Hundreds rally in Times Square to protest Donald Trump’s transgender military ban

“I’m out here to support my trans brothers and sisters who have been serving our military for years and years and years."

Several Republicans are strongly denouncing Trump’s military transgender ban

“Anybody who wants to serve in the military should serve in the military. I don’t agree with the president.”

Worried Trump might pardon himself? Blame Alexander Hamilton.

Hamilton might not have been "thinkin' past tomorrow" when he pushed for broad executive privileges.

Harry Truman desegregated the military 69 years ago. Today, Trump banned transgender troops.

Truman wanted to end discrimination in the military "as rapidly as possible."

Here is a timeline of Donald Trump’s relationship with Jeff Sessions

Trump continued his Twitter attacks on Sessions Wednesday — reportedly while the embattled attorney general was in the White House.

How many transgender people serve in the U.S. military?

There's no exact number, but here's what research shows.

Hundreds rally in Times Square to protest Donald Trump’s transgender military ban

“I’m out here to support my trans brothers and sisters who have been serving our military for years and years and years."

Several Republicans are strongly denouncing Trump’s military transgender ban

“Anybody who wants to serve in the military should serve in the military. I don’t agree with the president.”

Worried Trump might pardon himself? Blame Alexander Hamilton.

Hamilton might not have been "thinkin' past tomorrow" when he pushed for broad executive privileges.

Harry Truman desegregated the military 69 years ago. Today, Trump banned transgender troops.

Truman wanted to end discrimination in the military "as rapidly as possible."

Here is a timeline of Donald Trump’s relationship with Jeff Sessions

Trump continued his Twitter attacks on Sessions Wednesday — reportedly while the embattled attorney general was in the White House.

How many transgender people serve in the U.S. military?

There's no exact number, but here's what research shows.