George Zimmerman Judge Recuses Herself From Trayvon Martin Case

Circuit Judge Jessica Recksiedler recused herself on Wednesday from the George Zimmerman case because of her ties to a lawyer and CNN legal analyst who has been outspoken about the case. The case will be heard instead by Judge Kenneth Lester.

Judges are expected to recuse, or disqualify, themselves from a case in which they have a genuine or apparent conflict of interest. This policy aims to preserve the integrity and fairness of the courts, so the public will not question the court’s impartiality.

Judge Recksiedler is married to a lawyer who is a partner in the same firm as Mark NeJame, a CNN legal analyst who has been outspoken about this case and who at one time considered the possibility of representing George Zimmerman.

A genuine conflict of interest results where a judge stands to gain in some way from the outcome of the case. Indirect gains by judges from spousal earnings has been controversial — Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas recently faced criticism and calls for his recusal from the Affordable Care Act case because of his wife Ginni’s career in conservative activism, including advocacy against “Obamacare.” Recusal is generally left to the judge’s own discretion, and Justice Thomas chose to preside over that case.

Here, it does not seem that Judge Recksiedler had any conflict of interest. NeJame is not representing Zimmerman, and thus no shared profits resulting from the case could make their way to the judge’s husband. Nevertheless, Judge Recksiedler’s ties to NeJame could lead to an appearance of a conflict, given his continued commentary on the case.

In such a high profile trial as Zimmerman’s, where prejudice already factors into the public’s perception of the case, Judge Recksiedler is perfectly justified in recusing herself — even if she did not have to.

How much do you trust the information in this article?

Jason Orr

Jason is a student at Harvard Law School and writes on legal and policy issues. A 2009 graduate of the College of William and Mary, he worked at the Institute for Justice in Arlington, Virginia, before reentering academia. Jason's views have been published in a number of print and online news outlets, including the Washington Post and the Daily Caller.

MORE FROM

‘New York Times’ interview sparks latest wave of GOP frustration with Trump

The President’s “disturbing” comments on Jeff Sessions and Special Counsel Robert Mueller drew sharp rebukes from his own party.

Jordan Edwards’ mother speaks out after Monday’s indictment of the officer who killed her son

“We will not allow Jordan’s death to be another statistic.”

Trump keeps saying he wants to “let Obamacare fail.” How would that happen?

There are several ways the administration could sabotage the law, experts said.

AIDS deaths are almost half of what they were in 2005 — but experts worry Trump could reverse that

Trump's proposed budget cuts could be detrimental for those living with HIV.

OJ Simpson granted parole after nine years in prison

After serving nine years in prison for a 2007 armed robbery, OJ Simpson was granted parole in a unanimous vote on Thursday.

Black Lives Matter activists respond to the police shooting of Justine Damond

“Some white people don’t feel the tragedy until one of them is murdered.”

‘New York Times’ interview sparks latest wave of GOP frustration with Trump

The President’s “disturbing” comments on Jeff Sessions and Special Counsel Robert Mueller drew sharp rebukes from his own party.

Jordan Edwards’ mother speaks out after Monday’s indictment of the officer who killed her son

“We will not allow Jordan’s death to be another statistic.”

Trump keeps saying he wants to “let Obamacare fail.” How would that happen?

There are several ways the administration could sabotage the law, experts said.

AIDS deaths are almost half of what they were in 2005 — but experts worry Trump could reverse that

Trump's proposed budget cuts could be detrimental for those living with HIV.

OJ Simpson granted parole after nine years in prison

After serving nine years in prison for a 2007 armed robbery, OJ Simpson was granted parole in a unanimous vote on Thursday.

Black Lives Matter activists respond to the police shooting of Justine Damond

“Some white people don’t feel the tragedy until one of them is murdered.”