The BRAIN Initiative: Over-hyped or Undervalued?

Source: AP
Source: AP

When President Obama announced the Brain Research through Advancing Innovative Neurotechnologies (BRAIN) Initiative last April, it sent a buzz through the neuroscience community. Described as the "moonshot" for brain research, the $100 million, 10-year research project aimed to create the toolkit needed to study and understand the brain. But recently, it's come under fire for being underfunded and overpromised. While it's encouraging that this administration understands the importance of investing in neuroscience research, the BRAIN Initiative won't live up to its expectations. At best, researchers will have better tools to begin studying more complex issues such as consciousness. At worst, the already tight funding for such an ambitious project will be cut, or the specific projects awarded will be too fragmented, leaving us with disjointed results instead of a cohesive initiative. At the Society for Neuroscience's annual meeting in San Diego this week, government officials were on hand to address current concerns.

Officials remained energized and optimistic about the goal of "revolutionizing our understanding of the human brain." Yet, with the bar set so high and research dollars remaining low, funding is a primary concern. Tom Insel, director of the National Institutes of Mental Health, announced that no new money will go towards the BRAIN Initiative, and funds will be redistributed instead from ongoing projects and discretionary budgets. This decentralized approach worries current researchers who fear this will take money away from projects that don’t fall under the BRAIN Initiative’s priorities, and lead neuroscientists to pursure other sources of funding.

Insel noted that the National Institutes of Health (NIH) spends about $5.5 billion each year on neuroscience research. For the 2014 fiscal year, $40 million has already been set aside for the NIH to jump start the project. Geoffrey Ling, deputy director of the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) added that this project is not a windfall to throw money at a problem, but an attempt to create a new model for research and collaboration across agencies.

Public interest in the brain is at an all-time high, and the progress over the past few years has been extraordinary. Yet with interest and progress come expectations, and many fear that the BRAIN Initiative will not be able to deliver. Ling addressed this concern and explained the research would be deliverables driven. "Researchers will be competing agianst the clock instead of each other to either meet their milestones or change course," he assured the audience. In October, DAPRA announced they would spend $70 million dollar to focus on Deep Brain Stimulation research, with the ambitious goal of having a device ready for FDA approval in only 5 years. Moreover, Ling added that US researchers would collaborate and share data with the many similar projects already underway around the globe to further progress.

Researchers are only beginning to scratch the surface of understanding the brain. Unfortunately, the tools needed to dig deeper do not yet exist. The BRAIN Initiative, which may be able to help create that toolkit, has admirable goals with optimistic supporters. While it is a promising start, its leadership should be careful not to overpromise, especially in such a turbulent political climate. Hopefully at next year’s conference, there will be more answers than questions.  

How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Melissa Malski

Melissa has a bachelor’s degree in behavioral sciences and a master's in communications. She is interested in the relationship between media and behavior, and how it can potentially influence health. Huffington Post Live: Millennials Fighting Back: http://live.huffingtonpost.com/r/segment/can-millennials-achieve-the-american-dream/51dde6012b8c2a31770003b2

MORE FROM

How to use the Snapchat Map while everyone else continues to be confused about it

Everything you need to know about the new feature.

Planet 10? Scientists may have discovered a hidden planet in our solar system

There could be a ninth — or even 10th — planet hiding out in our solar system.

Scientists created a robot that will iron your clothes for you

Shut up and take my money.

Moth eyes have inspired the touchscreen of the future

It's going to change the anti-reflection game.

Twitter was flagging tweets including the word "queer" as potentially "offensive content"

Why Twitter put the word "queer" in the same category as violent, sexual imagery.

How Mark Zuckerberg wants to transform society through Facebook Groups

Facebook has a new mission.

How to use the Snapchat Map while everyone else continues to be confused about it

Everything you need to know about the new feature.

Planet 10? Scientists may have discovered a hidden planet in our solar system

There could be a ninth — or even 10th — planet hiding out in our solar system.

Scientists created a robot that will iron your clothes for you

Shut up and take my money.

Moth eyes have inspired the touchscreen of the future

It's going to change the anti-reflection game.

Twitter was flagging tweets including the word "queer" as potentially "offensive content"

Why Twitter put the word "queer" in the same category as violent, sexual imagery.

How Mark Zuckerberg wants to transform society through Facebook Groups

Facebook has a new mission.