This Rejection Letter Is One of the Biggest Mistakes in Music History

 This Rejection Letter Is One of the Biggest Mistakes in Music History

In 1979, 3 1/2 years after drummer Larry Mullen, Jr. started asking around his high school to see if anyone wanted to start a band, U2 had most of an album written and nobody who wanted to release it.

That year, Paul Hewson (aka Bono) wrote to RSO Records to inquire about a record contract. RSO was a good label, albeit one with an unfortunate logo (see below). In their day, they represented the Bee Gees, Eric Clapton and Andy Gibb. But they didn't want anything to do with U2, and sent "Mr. Hewson" this rejection letter: 


It only took a few years for the band to prove that this was a mistake.

U2's best music sounds like resilience and faith because that's what the members stand for. And in spite of the rejection, they made their record. A little more than four months later, the band released U2:3, an EP featuring the single "Out of Control," which topped the charts in Ireland.


The next year, they released their first full-length album, Boy, and their first big hit, "I Will Follow."


RSO Records folded in 1983, four years after that letter was sent and the same year that U2 released "Sunday Bloody Sunday." Over 30 years later, U2 performed "Ordinary Love," a song about Nelson Mandela, at the Academy Awards. This spring, they'll release their 13th studio album.

But U2 isn't inspiring because they made it when RSO couldn't. Even in success, they were — and are — continuously failing. On the web, where this article will live, they barely generate any buzz anymore. And this isn't the first time they've had to go away and "dream it all up again."

But these early songs remind of something important. To listen to U2 is to remember that they are defined less by a consistent sound than an insistent hope. The band's career is marked by its yearning — its unflagging search for a sound that actually could change the world — not its success.

Today, they're the same band they were in 1979: inspiring not because they've succeeded, but because they won't let go, even when it seems like they might be gone.

How much do you trust the information in this article?

Ben Naddaff-Hafrey

Ben moved to NYC in October. He is currently the editor of the Mic Music section. He graduated from Harvard in 2013 with a degree in American History & Literature and a secondary in Mind/Brain/Behavior. Outside of work, he is an active musician.

MORE FROM

Know who’s really winning ‘Game of Thrones’ this season? The show’s editing team

Props to Crispin Green and Tim Porter for episodes one and two, respectively. Y'all are some gross monsters.

TJ Miller’s explanation of the “feminist agenda” in ‘The Emoji Movie’ proves the bar is too low

How feminist can a movie with no female writers really be?

On Lana Del Rey’s lust for social consciousness

For her latest studio full-length, LDR proves there's more to her than the flower-crown aesthetic.

‘Game of Thrones’ Theories: Arya and Nymeria finally reunited, but what does it mean?

So, is Arya actually heading back to Winterfell?

‘Game of Thrones’: So Samwell Tarly is basically George R.R. Martin, right?

Finally, Jon Snow's sidekick has a greater purpose.

‘Game of Thrones’: Everyone's true nature is exposed in "Stormborn"

WE WERE ALL ROOTING FOR YOU, THEON!

Know who’s really winning ‘Game of Thrones’ this season? The show’s editing team

Props to Crispin Green and Tim Porter for episodes one and two, respectively. Y'all are some gross monsters.

TJ Miller’s explanation of the “feminist agenda” in ‘The Emoji Movie’ proves the bar is too low

How feminist can a movie with no female writers really be?

On Lana Del Rey’s lust for social consciousness

For her latest studio full-length, LDR proves there's more to her than the flower-crown aesthetic.

‘Game of Thrones’ Theories: Arya and Nymeria finally reunited, but what does it mean?

So, is Arya actually heading back to Winterfell?

‘Game of Thrones’: So Samwell Tarly is basically George R.R. Martin, right?

Finally, Jon Snow's sidekick has a greater purpose.

‘Game of Thrones’: Everyone's true nature is exposed in "Stormborn"

WE WERE ALL ROOTING FOR YOU, THEON!