Turns Out Telling White People About America's Racist Prison System Actually Backfires

Source: Getty
Source: Getty

White people seem to believe that more black prisoners is a sign of an effective criminal justice system, even when they have the racial inequalities of that system waved in front of their noses.

That's according to a new study out of Stanford University, that tested how increasing white people's awareness of disproportionate incarceration rates for whites and blacks would affect their views on incarceration laws. Two experiments, one conducted in San Francisco and the other in New York City, showed white subjects a series of mug shots. Those who saw more black faces among the mug shots were less likely to sign petitions advocating prison reform.

Of the joint study, Stanford researcher Rebecca Hetey concluded, "Many legal advocates and social activists seem to assume that bombarding the public with images, statistics and other evidence of racial disparities will motivate people to join the cause and fight inequality. But we found that, ironically, exposure to extreme racial disparities may make the public less, and not more, responsive to attempts to lessen the severity of policies that help maintain those disparities."

It seems that when it comes to racism and the prison system, honesty may not always be the best policy.


Image Credit: AP

The study's outcome may very well have significant ramifications for activists trying to change the criminal justice system. Current strategy tends to employ logic: Institutionalized racism is evident in the structures of society, one of which is the prison industrial complex. The sheer fact that 40% of the nation's prison population is black — nearly four times the percentage of the entire population — is statistical evidence that the criminal justice system disproportionally affects, if not targets, the black community. 

Yet Hetey and Eberhardt seem to have proven that activists should consider inverting their strategy. "Our research shows that numbers don't always speak for themselves," Jennifer Eberhardt noted. "Reducing inequality takes more than simply presenting people with evidence of extreme inequality."

One might argue that this shocking result is the product of the psychology of racism, a domain in which rational science and statistics hold less influence. Hetey and Eberhardt's study suggests that the more black faces a white person sees in a mug shot sequence, the more likely that white person believes not that the criminal justice system is racist, but that all those black faces are proof that black people are guilty. It's a perversion of the "colorblind" viewpoint, that surely these black faces are incarcerated because the criminal justice system would never incarcerate innocent people. 

This implied societal blindness when it comes to institutional racism dovetails nicely with an earlier study by two psychologists at Northwestern University investigating how white people react to the possibility of losing their majoritarian status. 

"On the Precipice of a 'Majority-Minority' America: Perceived Status Threat from the Racial Demographic Shift Affects White Americans' Political Ideology" by Maureen A. Craig and Jennifer A. Richeson proved that when a racial majority believes that its majority status has been threatened, there is a correlative uptick in the amount of fear and loathing directed at the racial group perceived to threaten that status. 

The Stanford study, one might argue, is an extension of this point. Instead of seeing racism, the study subjects saw a way to shore up their majority status. Either way, it's not very encouraging news for prison reform advocates in the United States.


How likely are you to make Mic your go-to news source?

Marcie Bianco

Dr. Marcie Bianco is a Staff Writer at Mic, a Contributing Editor at Curve Magazine, and an adjunct associate professor at Hunter College. She has contributed to AfterEllen, Feministing, The Feminist Wire, The Huffington Post, Lambda Literary, XO Jane, and The Women’s Review of Books. She writes and lectures about ethics, from feminism to race relations. Her current writing projects include a manuscript about lesbian academic affairs and a collection of feminist essays.

MORE FROM

Dow Jones won’t talk about its reported pay gap problem

A study released by the union representing Dow Jones employees found evidence of a "significant pay gap between men and women" who had the same job title and level of experience.

Mom slams ACA repeal, shows what's at stake in a tweetstorm about son's health

This mom says that without the ACA, her son wouldn't get the medical care he desperately needs.

Theresa May announces pact with Northern Ireland's conservative DUP

10 of the DUP's MPs will vote alongside May's party in exchange for more than $1 billion of funds.

Supreme Court will hear case of baker who refused service to gay couples on religious grounds

The Supreme Court will take on the case of a bakery owner who refused to bake a cake for a gay couple.

'Hot Mic' podcast: Health care opposition, Trump on Russian meddling & Pakistan tanker explosion

The important stories to get you caught up for Monday morning.

Dozens missing after tourist boat carrying more than 160 passengers sinks in Colombia

At least six people are confirmed dead and dozens more unaccounted for.

Dow Jones won’t talk about its reported pay gap problem

A study released by the union representing Dow Jones employees found evidence of a "significant pay gap between men and women" who had the same job title and level of experience.

Mom slams ACA repeal, shows what's at stake in a tweetstorm about son's health

This mom says that without the ACA, her son wouldn't get the medical care he desperately needs.

Theresa May announces pact with Northern Ireland's conservative DUP

10 of the DUP's MPs will vote alongside May's party in exchange for more than $1 billion of funds.

Supreme Court will hear case of baker who refused service to gay couples on religious grounds

The Supreme Court will take on the case of a bakery owner who refused to bake a cake for a gay couple.

'Hot Mic' podcast: Health care opposition, Trump on Russian meddling & Pakistan tanker explosion

The important stories to get you caught up for Monday morning.

Dozens missing after tourist boat carrying more than 160 passengers sinks in Colombia

At least six people are confirmed dead and dozens more unaccounted for.