Rudy Giuliani's comments come back to haunt Trump admin in Muslim ban hearing

Rudy Giuliani's comments come back to haunt Trump admin in Muslim ban hearing
Source: AP
Source: AP

Former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani's Fox News interview admitting President Donald Trump's executive order banning all refugees and nationals of seven Muslim-majority countries was originally conceived as a way to fulfill Trump's campaign promise of a Muslim ban, has come back to haunt the administration in court.

During a 9th Circuit Court hearing on the executive order Tuesday evening, lawyers for the states of Washington and Minnesota as well as justices on the court pressured Trump's DOJ on whether Trump and Giuliani's use of the term ban, among similar comments from other administration officials, revealed an intent to discriminate against Muslims trying to enter the country.

One justice on the court, George W. Bush appointee Richard R. Clifton, seemed initially skeptical of the claim that the order discriminated against all Muslims. Noah G. Purcell, the Washington state attorney, shot back "We do not need to prove" that the order "harms every Muslim," just that the order was intended as a form of religious discrimination.

In general the justices seemed skeptical of the administration's defense of the ban, the New York Times reported, though the appeals hearing was only over whether to lift a stay on the order imposed by another court. A ruling was not handed down and is expected this week.

Jake Miller contributed additional reporting to this article.

How much do you trust the information in this article?

Tom McKay

Tom is a staff writer at Mic, covering national politics, media, policing and the war on drugs. He is based in New York and can be reached at tmckay@mic.com.

MORE FROM

Trump asked his advisers about his ability to pardon his family and himself

Trump is reportedly looking for ways to block Mueller's investigation and is concerned that Mueller will look at his tax returns.

Prominent alt-right troll responds to ADL’s hate designation with Auschwitz video

The provocateur used the famous Nazi death camp to warn the Jewish civil rights group about hate.

Bernie Sanders makes first move against a bill with bipartisan support that could increase fracking

"Our job is to move away from fossil fuels toward sustainable energy and energy efficiency. This bill does the opposite."

Betsy DeVos calls protests against her a “badge of honor”

Hundreds gathered to protest her speech before a notorious conservative group.

Report: Paul Manafort is being investigated for possible money laundering by Special Counsel Mueller

The Senate has already asked Manafort to testify in open session next week.

Experts explain why the FBI has never — and should never — report to the president

“The president perhaps isn’t a student of our history.”

Trump asked his advisers about his ability to pardon his family and himself

Trump is reportedly looking for ways to block Mueller's investigation and is concerned that Mueller will look at his tax returns.

Prominent alt-right troll responds to ADL’s hate designation with Auschwitz video

The provocateur used the famous Nazi death camp to warn the Jewish civil rights group about hate.

Bernie Sanders makes first move against a bill with bipartisan support that could increase fracking

"Our job is to move away from fossil fuels toward sustainable energy and energy efficiency. This bill does the opposite."

Betsy DeVos calls protests against her a “badge of honor”

Hundreds gathered to protest her speech before a notorious conservative group.

Report: Paul Manafort is being investigated for possible money laundering by Special Counsel Mueller

The Senate has already asked Manafort to testify in open session next week.

Experts explain why the FBI has never — and should never — report to the president

“The president perhaps isn’t a student of our history.”